On Tuesday, Jerry Jones told 105.3 The Fan that the Cowboys were talking internally about defensive coordinator Christian Parker, but that he was not going to talk about it on the air. By Wednesday, the talking was over.
Parker is no longer calling the Dallas defense. ESPN's Todd Archer and Kimberley A. Martin, both friends of the show, reported that Mike Pettine, brought in to oversee things, is now calling the plays.
Rich was precise about what that means. Parker still holds the coordinator title, and he will presumably have a say in what the game plan looks like. "But when the game happens, that plan is going to be executed by another person," Rich said. "He's essentially been removed as defensive coordinator."
Something had to change. The Cowboys just gave up the most yards they have ever allowed in a home game, "whether the roof is closed or there was a hole in it so God could see his favorite team play," as Rich put it.
Rich laid out the possible readings. Maybe Parker is a scapegoat and the players are the ones who need to execute. Maybe the staff looked at film and asked why he called what he called. Maybe his work checked out and they simply wanted a different voice on game day. "Either way, they're just not going to sit back and just watch it all go down the tubes here."
He also felt for Parker, early in his career, and noted it happened to Sean Payton too. Payton had his play-calling taken away, then became a head coach and started removing play-callers of his own.
The bigger question for Rich is how Parker got hired in the first place, and who chose him. "At the end of the day, Jerry's going to have to make a call on the HC as well," he said.
The first test is the Titans. Cam Ward has played better over the last month, and Tony Pollard comes to town with a chance to make his mark against his old team. "This now makes it a much more interesting contest if you ask me," Rich said. Can Dallas hold an opponent under 20 points? That has not happened in a long time.
After that come the Thanksgiving game, visits to Seattle and to the Rams, who may have Puka back by then, then Jacksonville, which has been putting up 40 on people, then the Giants and a finale at Washington. Rich called the Giants game a must-win for the division.
TJ, the resident Cowboys fan, called it the right move. "Things weren't working, right? It's pretty obvious that the way things were going wasn't sustainable." Pressed on whether Dallas still makes the playoffs, he pulled a Belichick and refused to look past this week.
Chris Brockman was willing to say it: the Cowboys win the division. "I'm still not a Giants believer," Chris said. "We know the talent is there. So clearly it's the scheme not getting anything out of the players. It's coaching." His logic: put a coordinator with head coaching experience and top defensive experience in charge. "Clearly the moment was too big for Christian Parker and he couldn't handle it."
TJ added that Parker is a rookie at this, so expectations should have been tempered. Outside the front four, he said, the defense has not looked good, though they played great for about 20 minutes against the Niners. The desk still wants to know how Von Miller ended up covering McCaffrey.
Rich is sticking with New York. "I still think the G Men are winning this division. I still think at the end of the day they're a better coached team."
He sees winnable games for the Giants: Cleveland at home, a battle at Detroit, at Dallas and against Philadelphia. San Francisco and at Seattle are tough. At 5-3-1, he said, the Giants win the division by going 5-3 the rest of the way, it gets dicey at 4-5, and at 3-6 they can be had.
The Dallas version of the dream is simple: Pettine gets a defense to stop somebody and hold teams around 20, so that when Dak finds Pickens three times, CeeDee Lamb late once, and Javonte Williams racks up yards on the ground, the Cowboys win. Chris's math: get to nine wins and Dallas wins the division. The counter is that nine wins for the Giants would beat nine for Dallas, thanks to the tie on New York's record.
The whole country will be watching in a couple of weeks, with two NFC East teams sharing a slate with Bears and Lions and Chiefs and Bills. "They're trying," TJ said. "We haven't given up."
Rich's warning was blunt. If the Titans come in and put up 30, then it is time to look at the players. He had Dallas at the top of his power rankings early in the season. "They're not there anymore, FYI."
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.