Sean McVay is brilliant, Rich said. Which is exactly why the way he announced Puka Nacua's knee surgery jumped out.
"Puka Nacua decided to get surgery on his MCL on Tuesday," McVay said. "So that'll be a couple months for him." Out for the season? "Yeah, pretty much." McVay called it something the team always knew was a possibility, praised the communication from Nacua's side, and described it as "a learning op," something that "happened a while ago" with a lot of discussion behind the scenes.
Rich had played the clip for Daniel Jeremiah earlier, and DJ noticed the same thing Rich did: the phrasing.
Rich walked through it word by word. Decided to get. We always knew was a possibility. They were great in their communication with us. A learning opportunity.
"What's the learning opportunity?" he asked. He recalled a Schefter post showing Nacua's last run in the win over Washington, where he got blown up. That was the turf toe that led to him going on IR, in a game where he had 14 catches for 150 yards. So when did the knee happen? Was it that last play, or was it already bad enough that he still put up 150 yards? "So many questions coming out of this."
The crew turned it into a Friday question: Nacua is a free agent in March. Is he on the team next year?
"Great question, man," Rich said. Nacua got suspended for a reason, and there's a reason he hasn't been re-signed. For someone with his production, who is "such an avatar for the way that they want to play football" in McVay's system, you'd think he'd be locked up forever. Rich floated that maybe that's part of why Nacua said, no contract, I'll get my knee done, while stressing that it's "highly speculative."
Or maybe it simply got to the point where now was the time. Either way, Rich said, "He decided. Which is his right. It's his body." He's the one without a contract, and he wants to hit the market healthy.
The bigger question is whether the Rams can keep stacking wins without him. Rich thinks they're talented and deep enough. Davante Adams could be back. Myles Garrett is two weeks removed from a three-sack game, and Aaron Donald is two weeks removed from a game with a sack and a half, both with an extra week off. If the Rams sneak in as a six or seven seed, could Nacua come back for the playoffs?
McVay said that would be "getting way far ahead," that you'd never say no, but the healthy approach is to plan on not having him.
In the meantime, McVay has "fish to fry," as Rich put it. The Rams come off a bye into a short week. They have to protect Stafford from what looks like Micah Parsons and get the run game going.
TJ Jefferson brought up the Alonzo Mourning GIF from the bench and said that's Aaron Donald right now. Rich said it's everybody: McVay, Stafford, all of them.
And it's exactly why the rest of the league was saying "pump the brakes" when the Rams went all in. Rich remembered Dan Campbell being the first at a podium after the Garrett trade to joke that the season was over. "That's why brakes need to be pumped, because the football gods have a say in this thing, too," Rich said. The Rams were vastly improved, with Trent McDuffie and Garrett added and Donald returning, "but we didn't see all these other injuries coming. Nobody did."
So Rams fans are shaking their heads and nodding them at the same time. The head shake is disbelief. The nod is that they're still deep at running back, deep on the defensive line, deep on defense, and they have an MVP quarterback. Protect him, Rich said, "and there's many other ways to win."
It just isn't how anyone envisioned Thanksgiving week. Rich ran through the gauntlet: Green Bay on Wednesday, Kansas City the following Thursday, at San Francisco that Sunday to avoid a season sweep and keep division hopes alive, then Dallas at home and two games against Seattle. All of it without Nacua.
Rich's last thought was for Donald, and maybe a reason the Mourning face turns into a "hell yeah, let's do this thing." When Donald pointed to his ring finger in that stadium, Rich noted, Puka Nacua wasn't on the team yet.
Watch the full interview with Sean McVay on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.