“Unreal!” - Rich Eisen Reacts to CMC & the 49ers’ Nearly Hanging a 50-Burger on the Cowboys’ Defense
Watch on YouTube 2:41

“Unreal!” - Rich Reacts to CMC & the 49ers’ Nearly Hanging a 50-Burger on the Cowboys’ Defense

Part of the full interview: Just When We Thought the Dallas Cowboys’ Defense Couldn’t Get Worse… | The Rich Eisen Show

The Giants left the door open on Thursday night, and the Cowboys once again couldn't walk through it.

Rich laid out the NFC East math. The Washington Commanders, at 3-5-1, sit a half game behind Dallas but are in a better position to win the division, because they are 1-0 against the Giants. Washington just needs to finish two games better than New York the rest of the way. Their next game is against Cincinnati, which Rich, consulting his notes, called "not good for them."

As for Dallas, Rich has lost count of how many times the door has opened, the Cowboys have shown they can win and close, and then they haven't. "I've lost track," he said. "Which rhymes with Dak."

That brought the table back to an Overreaction Monday take from Chris Brockman: that Dak should step up and say he wants out. Chris said he and TJ had just been discussing it. "Dak just wants to play football and not worry about the sideshows," he said. The pushback: you can't be the Dallas Cowboys quarterback with that mindset, and as long as a team is paying him 60 million dollars, he's probably staying put. Chris thought Dak would take 50 somewhere else and be happy, even without CeeDee Lamb and Pickens, because there are good receivers across the league.

Then there's the coaching question. Nobody was sure whether Brian Schottenheimer sticks around, though Jerry doesn't typically turn coaches over.

The standings are the real problem. At 4-6, the Cowboys have to win the division. The studio noted that with three teams likely making it out of the North, even 6-4 teams like the Rams or Seahawks might miss the playoffs. "Four and six, they better win the division, cuz they're not making it as a seven seed." The room agreed. Still, one voice kept the door cracked, pointing to what just happened in New England: quarterbacks get hurt. "You can never say never."

Dak's own words after the loss sounded familiar. "Things got to get better. Simple as that," he said. "That was my message to the guys after the game, was we've got to be better, and it's on the field, it's off the field, it's in practice, it's in the way that we show up to the building." He added: "Haven't had back-to-back wins. It's tough. I do truly believe that we have the people, but something's got to change."

To the studio, it felt like Dak was waking up to the same game day over and over, cue the Groundhog Day radio alarm. When Dak was asked about that Groundhog Day feeling, he wasn't interested. "I really couldn't even give you the Groundhog Day analogy to be honest," he said. "I control what I can control."

For the record, the room worked out that Groundhog Day is February 2nd, 12 days before a Super Bowl Rich noted nobody in the room's team is playing in, except maybe Mike, who is rooting for the Rams this year.

What frustrates Rich most is the talent on that defense. "So disappointing, man," he said, listing Quinnen Williams, Kenny Clark, Rashan Gary, Caleb Downs, Daron Bland and Overshown. "There are some players out there."

And yet San Francisco ran through them. The 49ers, with Kyle Shanahan dialing it up, put up 584 total yards without even having Mike Evans back. Keenan Allen "fits in like he's been part of their franchise forever," and Rich said Shanahan was dialing up "all sorts of matchup problems" for a defense that "couldn't find their gap, couldn't find their man, couldn't find their car keys almost." Dallas was up 16-10, and the Niners looked to be in a dogfight "until it wasn't." Now San Francisco is 8-1.

The breakdowns were glaring. Rich still can't figure out how Von Miller ended up covering Christian McCaffrey, and figured that had to be a Shanahan thing. Another voice at the table said Dallas played well at points, "but giving up 71, 70, 66 yard touchdowns is just like, what the heck is going on, man." On Deebo's end-around, it seemed like nobody was watching the ball, everyone just running to a spot. One comparison: kids' flag football, where reverses always go for touchdowns. One of the crew admitted to calling that play as a youth coach, and it worked.

So what's next? Dallas is home for Tennessee, then on Thanksgiving faces Philadelphia with whoever the Eagles run out there, potentially Joe Milton or Tanner McKee. Then comes Seattle on Monday night, under the lights in front of the 12s, against JSN and a run game that has returned. "They've got to be six and six," Rich said. "You've got a one-win Tennessee team and a shell of a Philadelphia Eagles team right in front of the whole country on Thanksgiving. You've got to win that one."

Rich then ran the Giants' path: Jacksonville next, a Jaguars team that just dropped 40 on Tennessee with Parker Washington "out of his skull," then a trip to Indianapolis. If New York splits those two, it goes from 5-3-1 to 6-4-1 while Dallas is on bye. Then the Giants get San Francisco, and "the Niners beat them like they beat you," making it 6-5-1 going into the week Dallas plays in Seattle. After that, the Giants go to Seattle themselves, then face Cleveland.

"Rich, I'm trying to get off this ride and you're trying to keep me on," came the plea from across the table.

The final reminder from the table: Dallas could have won that game. There was a fumble, and "it was right there."

Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
Topics
Segment
Related Clips
NFL Network’s Daniel Jeremiah Blasts Cowboys’ Lack of Effort on Defense | The Rich Eisen Show
NFL Network’s Daniel Jeremiah Blasts Cowboys’ Lack of Effort on Defense | The Rich Eisen Show
Rich Breaks Down the 4-6 Houston Texans’ Chances to Make the Playoffs
Rich Breaks Down the 4-6 Houston Texans’ Chances to Make the Playoffs
Is Puka Nacua Deciding to Get Surgery a Bad Omen about His Rams Future? | The Rich Eisen Show
Is Puka Nacua Deciding to Get Surgery a Bad Omen about His Rams Future? | The Rich Eisen Show
Rich Chronicles the Stunning Demise of the 3-8 Indianapolis Colts
Rich Chronicles the Stunning Demise of the 3-8 Indianapolis Colts