One year ago this week, the Indianapolis Colts were 8-2 and sitting on a bye. Rich wanted Colts fans to remember that snapshot, because the fall since then has been stunning.
Back then, Daniel Jones was in the middle of a career resurgence. Shane Steichen had his quarterback. Jonathan Taylor was squarely in the MVP mix before the race narrowed to Drake Maye and Matthew Stafford. And Indianapolis was ahead of a Jacksonville team that couldn't put four clean quarters together, whether in London against the Rams, a game Rich called, or back home against Pete Carroll's struggling Raiders.
Then came week 12, the Sunday of Thanksgiving week. The Colts went into the fourth quarter in Kansas City up 20-9 on the struggling Chiefs.
"If the Colts fans could just freeze it there," Rich said, channeling Dick Vitale. "Freeze it, freeze it, freeze it. Right there. That's the high watermark."
They blew the 11-point lead and lost in overtime. That started a streak that ran seven straight losses to end last season and two more to start this one. In between, Jones went down with an Achilles injury two weeks after that Kansas City game, "and he's not the same, the team's not the same, the results are not the same."
They were 8-3 after that loss in Kansas City. Now they're 3-8 after losing in Houston to open week 11. They led 3-0 and had a chance to go up 6-0. Then the Texans scored 26 unanswered. "It wasn't even close," Rich said.
Late in the game, Anthony Richardson got in. Rich said Steichen essentially handed him a mop, and you have to wonder why he isn't handing him the starting job. Rich understands the Colts have no confidence in Richardson, which is why they got Jones and why they made sure Jones came back from the Achilles. But what confidence can you have in Jones right now? "None," Rich said.
Taylor has gone from MVP candidate to "as pedestrian as it gets," 11 carries for 21 yards. "You're seeing more of Seth McGowan than him sometimes," Rich said. If he were owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon, he joked, he'd be writing a four-letter word over and over on that notepad.
Rich does love Taylor's accountability. After the game, Taylor said the offense has to look at itself. "We scored three points tonight. So who are we going to look at? It's us," he said, adding that they have to help a defense that can only play hard for so long.
"That's the accountability you want to hear from him," Rich said. "That's why you don't trade him." But you hold on to him, and the results keep getting worse.
It's hard to expect much from the offense, Rich said, after trading away a Pro Bowl offensive lineman and Josh Downs, the top receiver who asked out. And so many of Chris Ballard's moves to get back to that 8-2 form have gone sideways. Alec Pierce got a No. 1 receiver contract, then got hurt and has hardly played. Two weeks before that Kansas City loss last year, the Colts flipped two first-round picks to the Jets for Sauce Gardner, who stood on the sideline last night with an earbud in, unable to stay healthy enough to affect anything.
Now look at the draft order. The Jets' own pick sits fourth, with the Chargers currently holding the second overall choice ahead of their game against New York this weekend. The Colts' pick to the Jets is right behind, with only the Eagles in between, and Rich suspects Howie Roseman might trade out and let someone jump the Jets. That's draft intrigue for another day, he said, and for Daniel Jeremiah.
Rich didn't sugarcoat it. "It's hard to think that Shane Steichen is going to survive this," he said. A year ago, Steichen was 8-2 on a bye thinking they had this thing. Then seven losses to end the year, a missed postseason, two more losses to start this one. The Colts did win two in a row, including Miami a couple of weeks ago, but the win before that came in London against a Washington team that started Marcus Mariota and lost him on the first series. "Not much to write home about," Rich said.
"Colts fans, I wish I had a better outlook for you right now."
As someone on set put it, it's one of the worst situations in the NFL, which is rare to say about the Colts.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.