On a normal week, Rich would have spent the open celebrating the Buffalo Bills. A preseason AFC favorite with a quarterback in line to be MVP again goes on the road on Monday Night Football, beats a 6-1 team in its own building, and moves to 7-1. That is usually the story.
Not this week. This week, the story was Carson Wentz.
Going in, Wentz had one job. He needed to play well enough to give Minnesota a real choice between him and Kyler Murray, and well enough to stop talk of the Vikings doing something rash at the trade deadline. Rich wrote down how that went so he could read it on air.
"Carson Wentz did not," he said.
Then he went further. "He played the worst game any quarterback has played this year. And notice I didn't say arguably."
Wentz went 8 of 25 for 81 yards with two interceptions and a lost fumble. Rich wondered whether Wentz's play affected everyone in the building, including a moment when the rules analyst on the broadcast nearly explained that a forward pass has to go forward. "Affected me and I had nothing to do with the game," Rich said.
The numbers were brutal. Minnesota went 0 for 8 on third down, the first time in 13 years the team failed to convert one. Its negative offensive EPA was the second-worst for the franchise in any game in the last decade. It was the Vikings' third game this season without a touchdown, the most of any team. When not pressured, Wentz was off target 38 percent of the time and completed 36 percent of his passes, both the worst in the NFL this season by ESPN's tracking. His QBR was 2.3.
Rich had a theory about whoever does ESPN's tracking. If it's a computer, he joked, it was basically calling Claude to ask for an AI agent to come hack this quarterback.
Then came an "old gen stat." The Vikings are the first team since 1925 to win six of their first eight games despite three games without a touchdown. Two teams did it that year, the Detroit Panthers and the Frankford Yellow Jackets.
"Not a laughing matter," Rich said. "That was awful. And I can't even stress how soft a word that is."
Kevin O'Connell owned it at the podium. "In no way, shape or form was tonight acceptable," he said. He told his team it starts with him, said the defense was on the field too much, and said the team "never got Carson in a rhythm." He added that they tried a bunch of tools to make that happen "and I didn't do a good enough job doing that."
Wentz was candid too. "I felt good. Honestly, I felt good. The building was rocking," he said. "What better atmosphere can you ask for Monday night here and to go kind of lay an egg?" He said the defense played as well as it has all year, "and we just didn't help them out," and admitted it was hard to put his finger on why.
Rich gave him credit for talking and owning it. Then he delivered the verdict. "He should be like Paulie from The Godfather. You won't see him no more."
Justin Jefferson was asked about his confidence in the quarterbacks on the roster. He said it doesn't really matter who's throwing the ball, "as long as it gets to us." Rich credited Jefferson for facing the media, and said he word-saladed it on purpose, because anything stronger in either direction would have been thrown back in his lap.
O'Connell was asked whether a trade for a quarterback was possible. He deferred to Nolan, whom Rich identified as general manager Nolan Teasley, hired in June. O'Connell said they had talked about a lot of different positions and would "get right to work" on any potential moves.
Rich's view of where it goes from here: Wentz made Murray look like Fran Tarkenton. Minnesota went 6-1 before this game, many of those with Murray, so the Vikings can get him back and hope he stays healthy. They cannot put Wentz on the field again. Max Brosmer came in at the end and looked more in rhythm, though against a Bills defense that probably didn't have many starters out there.
Then there is the decision that hurts most. Minnesota could have had a quarterback who has won six straight starts. That's J.J. McCarthy, now leading the first-place Giants after the Vikings traded him for a fifth-round pick. Rich would love to know what happened to make them want him out of the building that badly.
"Right now, you're watching that game last night," Rich said. "You're like, what in the world was that decision all about?"
If they want to make a move, they have the ammunition. Rich ran through the board: their own first and second, two thirds including one from Philadelphia in the Jonathan Greenard deal, and three fifths, one from Carolina in the Adam Thielen trade and one from the Giants for McCarthy.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.