The Giants had the Commanders on the ropes, had a chance to all but lock them out of the NFC East, and let it slip away. Rich's diagnosis was simple: this one should make Giants fans sick.
It started as a revenge game for Cam Skattebo. The last time these teams met in Washington, in Week 5, Skattebo coughed up the football in overtime. He then disappeared for a game. The Giants brass said they weren't teaching him a lesson. Skattebo basically said he was benched and in the doghouse. He came back with a great game against the Texans.
The quarterback picture has changed a lot since then, too. Rich reminded everyone that JJ McCarthy "had no idea he'd be starting this game for the Giants in Week 10" back in Week 5. McCarthy came on for Jameis Winston against the Saints in Week 6, got the start in Week 7 and beat the Texans, then beat the Eagles in Philadelphia for the Giants' first win there in a dozen years.
On Thursday, Skattebo was a house of fire. "He did it all," came the summary from the desk. "He flipped, he scored twice, he vomited at his feet, covered it with a towel." Rich saluted Kaylee Hartung for what he called the sideline report of the year: he just vomited right where he's sitting, covered his mess with a towel, back to you. "That's the information. What a sideline reporter."
McCarthy kept the Giants on schedule. Rich praised him for "not going broke, taking the profit, moving it down the field, not turning it over," then uncorking some top-of-the-food-chain throws, including one to Isaiah Likely over the middle where Likely looked like he was about to take a shot and somehow didn't.
But the mistakes piled up. Malik Nabers coughed one up on a drive that looked headed for points. Dominic Zvada, a fellow Michigan man of Rich's and McCarthy's, missed "another bunny," three points that would have sent the game to overtime. Zvada also kicked a ball toward the sideline, and Luke McCaffrey made a brilliant play to lay out and grab it before it went out of bounds. Instead of getting the ball at the 3, Washington got it at the 40.
Even then, the Giants had chances. Jevon Holland picked off Jayden Daniels. The Giants then went three-and-out, but not before a pre-snap moment Rich could not let go: Jameis Winston, at the line, doing "Who Let the Dogs Out" to try to draw the defense offside. Rich said it was the first time he'd heard the Baha Men at a big New York sporting event since they performed before Game 3 of the Subway Series.
"It's Jameis. It's funny," Rich said. "I'm laughing, but it ain't funny now when the Giants lose this game."
Then the Giants picked off Daniels again, with 2:10 left. "All you need to do is basically get a first down or two and this thing's a wrap," Rich said. Instead, they didn't put the ball in McCarthy's hands and gave it back. Daniels went right down the field, found Stefon Diggs for the score, and the Commanders started blitzing on the final drive. McCarthy put up two 50-50 balls and was hit as he threw, and a Washington interception ended it.
"Commanders season saved," Rich said. "Giants' opportunity to lock them out. It would have been a two-team race."
John Harbaugh kept it measured. "It's a missed opportunity, but like I told the guys, it would have been great to win the game, but it doesn't change our goals or our opportunity going forward," he said. "Everybody in this league is good. The Commanders are good... And we got a really good team coming in here next Sunday. A team that we can beat."
That would be the Jaguars, and Rich figured Liam Coen might pin that line to the bulletin board.
Still, Rich made clear the Giants are far from dead. At 5-3-1 they lead the NFC East, a game and a half up on a Cowboys team facing the 49ers, and Rich declared the Eagles finished, hearing no pushback in the room. The remaining schedule includes Jacksonville, Indianapolis, San Francisco, Seattle, Cleveland, Detroit, Dallas and Philadelphia. "They could still win this division. No doubt about it."
The problem is what Thursday cost them. Instead of being 2-0 against Washington, the Giants are 0-1-1 against the one team positioned to run them down. "It's a missed opportunity," Rich said, "which is what he said, too."
Watch the full interview with Cam Skattebo on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.