Red Sox P Payton Tolle Talks Movember, Superstitions, Karaoke More with Rich Eisen | Full Interview
Watch on YouTube 19:28

Red Sox P Payton Tolle Talks Movember, Superstitions, Karaoke More with Rich

Rich is a Yankees fan, and he still couldn't help himself. Payton Tolle, he said, is "fun to watch," "fun to root for" and "difficult to root against." The Red Sox pitcher came on in support of Movember, though as Rich noted, with that mustache every month is Movember for him.

Tolle returned the favor, calling it an honor to talk with "the best dad ever." The tone was set.

A wedding, a honeymoon and a very specific sunburn

Tolle got married over the All-Star break and had just returned from his honeymoon in Barbados. They snorkeled, did some rum tasting and mostly relaxed. He also came home with "a big old circle" of sunburn around his stomach. He has no idea how it happened. "I need to proofread SPF on my sunscreen, I guess," he said.

The wedding itself was small by design. The couple didn't want a long engagement, so they picked the All-Star break, got family together, and Tolle played golf with his dad and brother before the ceremony. After dinner, they hit a karaoke bar.

Rich had to stop him right there. What's Payton Tolle's go-to karaoke song?

He thinks he accidentally sang "Accidentally in Love" by Counting Crows that night. But his signature is a duet with his brother: "Islands in the Stream." Who sings the Dolly Parton part? "I feel like I can do a really good Dolly Parton," Tolle said, "so I will not be showcasing that right now." Rich agreed that was best left to the imagination.

Then Rich asked the follow-up he'd been sitting on: what if Tolle had made the All-Star team? He figured they would have pushed the wedding to the offseason or something, and joked that he hoped he wasn't now in trouble. Rich apologized for putting him in that spot, but pointed out it was a legitimately fair question this early in Tolle's career. Tolle said there were a couple of moments where they talked about staying flexible, but then a guy like Sonny Gray doesn't make the All-Star Game "and it's like, what are we even doing here?"

King of the hugs

Rich introduced Chris Brockman, a die-hard Red Sox fan, who mostly just wanted to say thank you. Tolle said he wished he could give him a hug, and Rich called him "the king of the hugs."

How is he so present during games? Tolle said he learned early, starting with his debut at Fenway, that when a moment happens, you take it in, because it doesn't happen everywhere. "I love baseball, so I want to show people why," he said, and he likes moments where people can laugh with him "and not at me, because there were a couple of moments this year where people were laughing at me."

Fenway's energy is the best part of pitching there. Even when things weren't going well, the fans showed up, and during the 15-game streak "you can ride the wave of it." He's been inside the Green Monster, too, and was impressed by the workers given how sticky it must get in July without much AC.

Movember, and the broken razor

Tolle said he's enjoyed learning more about Movember, which he called a leader in men's health awareness, and the mustache has taken on "a personality of its own." Rich ran through the issues the organization tackles: mental health, suicide prevention, prostate and testicular cancer, the things men usually don't talk about. Fans can find the PSAs through Movember USA on Instagram and Tolle's own account.

The beard is back for a practical reason. He opened his case and found his razor in two pieces. His wife likes it, and the mustache return is close.

Asked if there will be baseball next year, Tolle pivoted exactly as instructed. "I will pivot to what I've been told to say and say, let's talk about Movember." Rich called it a good pivot.

Freeman, superstitions and the Sexy Boy

The toughest hitter so far is a guy he watched growing up: Freddie Freeman, who went 3-for-3 with two doubles and a single in their one game. Someone described it to Tolle as watching a scratch golfer put the ball wherever he wants. Rich said not to feel bad. Freeman is "an equal opportunity abuser."

Superstitious? He tries to keep routine from becoming superstition, "but I'm a baseball player, so it is." He walks out to the same three songs from the weight room: "Black" by Pearl Jam, "Bullet with Butterfly Wings" by Smashing Pumpkins and Shawn Michaels' entrance theme. And he jumps the foul line, switching feet after a bad inning.

Fantasy football and famous faces

Tolle grew up in Oklahoma following football everywhere, including the Bills and Josh Allen for a bit, but he's claiming the Patriots because his first NFL game was a Patriots game. Rich wasn't buying the "not a bandwagon" defense.

In the Red Sox fantasy league, Tolle co-owns a team with his battery mate Adley, and it's going badly, around three wins entering week 11. Lesson learned: maybe don't pick 12th. Romy Gonzalez is near the top, and Aroldis Chapman's team has Jahmyr Gibbs, which Rich found very on brand. The team name stays private.

Can Tolle keep up with Chapman in the weight room? "Absolutely not." Watching him work since his call-up has been "just impressive," and Tolle believes Chapman is now the all-time strikeout leader among relievers.

The coolest people he's met? Fenway legends Pedro, Big Papi and Carl Yastrzemski. He and his wife also spotted Pat McAfee outside a hotel and went over to say hi. And he met Patrick Dempsey, McDreamy, through Dana-Farber and the Jimmy Fund, which Rich said his brother-in-law supports every year.

Rich promised not to wait until next November to have him back, and not to ask any more questions about lockouts or skipping weddings. The crew already had the next topic lined up: his love of Shawn Michaels. And yes, they closed by singing "Islands in the Stream."

Watch the full interview with Payton Tolle on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
People
Topics
Segment
In This Interview
A Vacation to Barbados with Red Sox P Payton Tolle Sounds Like a BLAST!!! | The Rich Eisen Show
A Vacation to Barbados with Red Sox P Payton Tolle Sounds Like a BLAST!!! | The Rich Eisen Show
Related Clips
Pat Murphy Is STILL Processing Winning the Brewers’ 1st World Series | The Rich Eisen Show
Pat Murphy Is STILL Processing Winning the Brewers’ 1st World Series | The Rich Eisen Show
Brewers Manager Pat Murphy on Bob Uecker’s Lasting Impact on Milwaukee | The Rich Eisen Show
Brewers Manager Pat Murphy on Bob Uecker’s Lasting Impact on Milwaukee | The Rich Eisen Show