Victor Wembanyama, on his 22nd birthday, became the youngest player in NBA playoff history to put up 40 points and 20 rebounds in a game. The Spurs took Game 1 of the Western Conference Finals in Oklahoma City. The conversation on the show was about exactly what we just watched.
Start with the moment that ended the night. The Spurs needed a three with 10 seconds left to send the game to a second overtime. Wembanyama pulled up from 28 feet on the run and made it.
"There's so many ways that can go right there," the room said. The instinct for most players at 10 seconds is to attack the rim, get the and-one, extend the game. Wembanyama did the harder thing. The cameras caught fans behind the basket reacting like physics had been suspended.
The closest comparable was Stephen Curry's late deep three from roughly the same spot years ago. Curry's release point is consistently 12 to 14 inches deeper than the average shooter, so the math is slightly different. But Curry was 6'3" with a regular wingspan. Wembanyama is 7'3" pulling up at 28 feet at his size.
The 40-and-20 night also closed a different loop. Pregame, Wembanyama stood courtside watching Shai Gilgeous-Alexander be presented the MVP trophy for the second straight year. He had finished in the top three in voting. He answered a question about it with a line that did exactly what a postgame quote should do.
"I still got a lot to learn," Wembanyama said. "I want to get that trophy many times in my career."
That answer drew praise from the room as a piece of media construction. He neither needed to confirm the chip on his shoulder nor deny it. The 40-and-20, with the 28-foot three on top, said it.
Mitch Johnson's postgame echoed the box score.
"His level of physicality and execution through physicality was tremendous," Johnson said. He praised Wembanyama's stance on defense, his rebounding, and the fact that he played 49 minutes at that level.
The harder question the show was wrestling with was whether last night was the night Wembanyama became the best player in the NBA. The room hedged. The argument against was about consistency. Wembanyama has played some genuinely bad games this postseason. Game 1 of the Minnesota series was the worst of them. The Timberwolves cracked him by getting physical with him, not by trying to match length for length.
That history is where Mark Daigneault's postgame answer becomes the structural pivot. The Thunder coach said the team's best quality is problem-solving and that Game 2 requires the team to figure something out.
The clues are in the film. Physicality changes Wembanyama. The catch is finding the body that can deliver it. Chet Holmgren, who did get the block at the end of regulation to force overtime, is not built to body up Wembanyama for an entire game. Lu Dort is short. Rudy Gobert tried it for Minnesota and the experiment failed in Games 5 and 6, but it did work in Game 1.
The bigger Oklahoma City problem is that SGA went 7-for-23, was minus 15, and the Thunder still only lost by seven. Alex Caruso was their best player on the floor, including catching one bizarre Wembanyama flop that Daigneault visibly reacted to on the sideline. De'Aaron Fox, whom the show speculated might be a Shai matchup answer in his own right, did not even play.
"If they're going to win this series," the analysis concluded, "their best player can't be Alex Caruso."
The Thunder have three to six games to solve the biggest problem in the league.
Watch the full interview with Chet Holmgren, Shai Gilgeous Alexander on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.