The Rich Eisen Top 5: Ranking the 2024 NFL Draft 1st-Round Quarterbacks
Watch on YouTube 4:44

The Rich Top 5: Ranking the 2024 NFL Draft 1st-Round Quarterbacks

Rich's Friday top five is usually reserved for the games of the week. Then a caller from Denver asked him to rank the quarterbacks from the 2024 draft class, a group with six first-rounders, and Rich decided to do it on the spot, off the top of his head.

He even flipped his usual format. Instead of counting up from five, he went from one down. Counting backward, he said, was "too much mental gymnastics."

Here is how it landed, based on what the group has shown so far.

**1. Caleb Williams**

Rich opened with a joke, briefly crowning J.J. McCarthy before correcting himself. "Number one's Caleb."

The pushback came immediately on behalf of Drake Maye, with the reminder that "one guy's been in the Super Bowl" and was second in MVP voting. Rich heard it and didn't budge. "Right now, where we are right now, and for the future I'm going with Caleb Williams," he said. "I think I will be proven correct."

**2. Drake Maye**

Maye came in second, and Rich offered a compromise for the room: "How about one and one A?"

That opened a short detour about the Patriots wanting Williams and the Joe Milton era. "Joe Milton is a nice guy," came the verdict, before Rich pulled everyone out of the wormhole.

**3. Jayden Daniels**

Rich admitted Daniels' spot leans on his rookie year. "It's amazing how we're still dining out a little bit on his first year," he said. Nobody argued when it was pointed out that Maye "has zoomed past him."

**4. Bo Nix**

This is where Rich said it got dicey, with Nix, Michael Penix Jr. and McCarthy bunched together. He stuck with Nix at four, with a caveat. "The way he is playing right now, he's playing the worst out of all three of them," Rich said. "And I just said those words."

Still, Rich pointed out that Nix won a divisional playoff game last year against Josh Allen, a club Rich believes includes only Joe Burrow, Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson. He checked that with Mike, the show's Bills and Josh Allen historian.

**5. Michael Penix Jr.**

A co-host made the case to put Penix fourth, arguing "Penix looks pretty good" and noting Sean Payton "hasn't done a good job coaching this year." That drew a "high register" alert from Rich, who still slotted Penix at five.

**The wild card: J.J. McCarthy**

That left McCarthy off the list, and the room was quick to call him the wild card. Rich, who referred to McCarthy as "one of my sons," said the quarterback could jump to fourth on this list by Sunday, and by the end of the year "he could get past Drake Maye."

The Maye camp set a higher bar. "If he wins a Super Bowl, yes, I will put him number one."

"What an opportunity for him," Rich said, before thanking the Denver caller for the "makeshift content."

Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
Segment
Related Clips
The Ringer’s Todd McShay on How Early a Non-QB Will be Drafted Next Spring | The Rich Eisen Show
The Ringer’s Todd McShay on How Early a Non-QB Will be Drafted Next Spring | The Rich Eisen Show
The Ringer’s Todd McShay’ Advice for Arch Manning: Transfer to Kentucky | The Rich Eisen Show
The Ringer’s Todd McShay’ Advice for Arch Manning: Transfer to Kentucky | The Rich Eisen Show
What Should the Chargers Do If They End Up with the #1 Pick in the NFL Draft? | The Rich Eisen Show
What Should the Chargers Do If They End Up with the #1 Pick in the NFL Draft? | The Rich Eisen Show
The Ringer’s Todd McShay Breaks Down ’27 NFL Draft QB Risers and Fallers | The Rich Eisen Show
The Ringer’s Todd McShay Breaks Down ’27 NFL Draft QB Risers and Fallers | The Rich Eisen Show