Rich's Top 5 was supposed to be five games. It ended up being six, and the order got argued over along the way.
The list covered the rest of Week 10 beyond the opener, and it started in Cleveland.
**No. 5: Texans at Browns.** Rich thinks Houston might be running out of weeks. "They got to keep winning right now. Their backs are against the wall," he said. "Six losses would be pretty tough to have through 10 weeks if you want to keep on matriculating." The team that can push them into the barrel is Deshaun Watson and a Browns squad that needs a win to keep pace in the division. Add CJ Stroud back in his college state of Ohio and Watson going against the Texans, and Rich sees a game where Watson "could put quite a nail in" the Texans.
**No. 4: Patriots vs. Lions in Germany.** Detroit has won several in a row and looked "pretty darn good in the process" last week. Rich figured the Lions hoped it would be easier against the Dolphins, but they took care of business. Now they head to Germany to face a Patriots team "fresh off of a pounding by the Green Bay Packers," the same Packers the Lions need to keep pace with. Rich is excited about the setting, too. "It's a great stadium, Allianz Arena. What an environment it's going to be."
**No. 3: 49ers at Cowboys.** This is where the debate started. The pitch from the studio was that this one will feel like an old-school game. Rich understood the history of the series but would not move it above his next pick. "The Cowboys are just trying to stay alive and keep pace at four and five, man."
**No. 2: Steelers vs. Bengals.** Sunday Night Football, with the AFC North on the line. "Aaron Rodgers against Joe Burrow and these defenses," Rich said. "I was even thinking of making that number one."
**No. 1: Vikings at Packers.** What kept the Steelers out of the top spot was Kirk Cousins. "Kirk Cousins is a Viking now," Rich said. "This is the first game and he's going back to the spot where his Achilles popped." The Vikings need him to start winning football games now to end a losing streak, and the Packers "are playing like they're playing." That was enough to win over the room. "Okay. You convinced me."
Then came the bonus. Asked whether one more was needed, the answer was "why not."
**Bonus: Panthers at Saints.** Rich did not care about the records. "First place is on the line in the NFC South." He also had a personal stake, pleading for a player he has been stashing to get back on the field. "I need him in every fantasy league that I've been stashing him in for weeks."
The studio had questions of its own about Carolina, mainly whether Jalen Coker was going to play and, half joking, whether he still plays football at all.
Rich's answer was the same either way. "Panthers, Saints, NFC South on the line. Come on now."
Five games became six. But the top spot never moved: Kirk Cousins, a Viking again, going back to the place where his Achilles popped.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.