Rich has seen enough Aaron Rodgers to know the real thing when it shows up. After Pittsburgh's win over the Saints in Paris, he said it plainly: Rodgers "is playing as well as we've seen him play since Green Bay."
The moment that sealed it came on the ground. Facing third-and-eight, Rodgers took off and picked up the first down that essentially wrapped up the game. Rich, who made the point on the postgame show, had a message for any Parisians attending their first NFL game who had studied up on YouTube. "That's vintage Rodgers," he said. "I see the green grass in front of me, I'm gone. Out the gate."
The run game around him has been just as important. Rich called the backfield pairing of Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle "a hell of a one-two punch."
The passing numbers are stacking up too. In the comeback win over the Buccaneers, DK Metcalf and Germie Bernard each caught 11 passes. Rodgers also hit Metcalf for a 51-yard gain that set up a touchdown, a throw that traveled 48 yards in the air, the longest air-yards pass of his Steelers tenure. Then he found tight end Darnell Washington in the end zone for the first touchdown, a play one viewer comment compared to an uncle dominating his eight-year-old nephew at the Turkey Bowl.
Sunday made it five straight games with a passing touchdown, Rodgers' second-longest streak since leaving the Packers, and it broke his tie with Peyton Manning for third on the all-time passing touchdowns list.
Rich gives a lot of the credit to the reunion with Mike McCarthy. With more than 20 years of experience "in that skull," Rodgers can diagnose defenses and call plays at the line, and Rich called him "definitely the greatest in the game right now, neck up." He and McCarthy go back, and right now all of it is working. So is the defense, which Rich said is "balling out," and the team is staying healthy.
That is a far cry from where Rich thought this team was headed. "I honestly watched Rodgers walk off the field in that playoff loss to the Texans thinking, 'That's it for him and this team's run out of gas,'" he said. Then Pittsburgh hired McCarthy and brought Rodgers back. "There's a ton of gas in this tank, guys. There really, really is."
The schedule makes the next game enormous. The Steelers return from Paris to host the Browns in Week 8, and Rich believes they want a piece of Cleveland "in the worst way." The Browns have earned that by beating Pittsburgh and continuing to win, and with the Bengals having just smoked the Ravens in the second half, Rich sees a division the Steelers can absolutely win before making some hay in the playoffs.
There was trivia too. Rodgers is now the first quarterback in NFL history to throw the first touchdown pass in two different countries: Ireland, to Metcalf last year, and France, to Washington this year. He won both games. Rich had leaned into that in his lead-in for NFL GameDay Kickoff, calling Rodgers a world traveler who climbs mountains in Peru, once went to Egypt during a Jets OTA, does darkness retreats in Oregon and walks the beaches in Malibu, plus wherever ayahuasca takes him.
So does he keep playing? A caller asked, and Rich does not think so. He sees a guy who looks like he is having fun and is out of Fs to give, even revealing at the podium that the league had once wanted international games for every team in the last collective bargaining talks before taking a 17th game instead. "I think he's gone," Rich said. "But before he does, he wants to leave a mark."
One more note on the roster build. Rich recalled the draft-night moment when the Steelers were about to take Makai Lemon and the Eagles snaked them, sending Pittsburgh to the offensive line with Max Iheanacho. Best-laid plans, Rich said. Germie Bernard is turning into the role he imagines Pittsburgh wanted Lemon to play, and seven games in he is already leaning into sideline conversations with Rodgers and Metcalf, game planning "like he's Jordy Nelson."
Through seven weeks, Rich's verdict on the Steelers was simple: "You can't argue with it."
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.