Rich does not have an answer for who earns the top seed in the AFC. What he has is a list of five teams that all could, and a warning for anyone who rules one out.
"I don't have an answer for you who's going to be the top seed in the AFC, but they will have earned it," he said. "And it's wide open right now."
The conversation started with the road ahead. Kansas City's late stretch is brutal: at Buffalo on Thanksgiving night, at the Rams, at Cincinnati, home for New England, which looks a lot better now, and home for San Francisco. Denver, coming off its bye, has Pittsburgh the Friday after Thanksgiving, then Miami at home, the Jets and Las Vegas on the road, and then Buffalo.
That made one missed opportunity loom large. Kansas City had Denver on its own one-yard line and did not cash in. "The same way the Giants could close out the Commanders and didn't, the Chiefs had a chance to close out the Broncos and didn't," Rich said. "That might be something you look back a month from now."
Rich put Cincinnati and Denver as having the easiest paths, with the Chiefs and Bills neck and neck. Then he turned to Jacksonville: at the Giants, home for Tennessee, at Chicago, a Monday nighter against Pittsburgh in Jacksonville, at Houston, at Dallas. "Jacksonville's got a really nice stretch here."
Kansas City was supposed to be one-dimensional, and then toast, after Kenneth Walker III was wiped out against Seattle. Then the Chiefs walked into Atlanta and "Emmett Johnson enters the chat," Rich said. The rookie from Nebraska became the first Chiefs rookie with 150 scrimmage yards and two touchdowns in a game, and the first Chiefs rookie running back with a touchdown in three straight games, both since Kareem Hunt in 2017.
Patrick Mahomes threw five touchdown passes, the seventh such game of his career. Three of them traveled 15 or more air yards, his most in a game since 2020, after none of those in the first eight games for a team known for dinking and dunking. New receiver Josh Downs caught a touchdown in his debut, the first Chiefs receiver with 50 receiving yards and a receiving touchdown in a team debut since Chris Chambers in 2009.
Mahomes explained how the trust came quickly. Early in the game Downs won on a route where Mahomes did not expect him to. "You see on the tablet and you're like, all right, he won," Mahomes said. "He's here for a reason and it's to make those plays and so I got to trust him to go out there and make the play and he proved that he can do it."
Rich rattled off the checklist. New receiver, backup running back, Brett Veach can draft and trade, Andy Reid can coach, so can Spagnuolo. "Boom, seven and two."
He also floated a theory that Mahomes is in the Belichick and Phil Jackson zone, so accomplished that voters stop considering him for the top award. The desk disagreed and pointed out Mahomes is fifth in MVP odds.
And to the Falcons, who just faced Burrow and Mahomes back to back: "Anybody want a piece of that?"
Buffalo's 31-12 win at MetLife reminded Rich of a big brother holding his little brother off by the forehead, Heisman-style, while the kid keeps swinging. Eventually one swing lands, and then you just shove him over.
James Cook went for 157 yards, helped by a 70-plus yard run late. The Bills are the only team unbeaten on the road this season, and their 8-1 start ties the second best nine-game start in franchise history. Josh Allen was not satisfied. "We're not playing our best football," he said. "Honestly, I think offensively we didn't play too well. I know you can look at the stat sheet and 31 points. Didn't feel like first half we executed the way we wanted to."
Steve in Florida called the WeatherTech fan line to defend his Jags, and to point out that Jacksonville beat Cincinnati, so even with the same record, the Jags would be ahead.
Rich agreed it matters. The Jaguars hit the Bengals just before Burrow's current five-game run of at least four touchdowns accounted for. Jacksonville is 15-2 over its last 17 regular season games, the best record in the NFL over that span. Rich praised Parker Washington as a top-notch receiver and Trevor Lawrence as "an elite MVP type quarterback." The Jaguars just won by 17 or more points for the fifth time this season, two more than anybody else. Steve's only real fear on the schedule: the Bears.
The desk also could not stop talking about Travis Hunter's interception.
So Rich ran the list. Can the Bills be the one seed? Yes. The Chiefs? Absolutely. The Bengals? "Oh, baby. Yeah, they can." The Broncos, coming off the bye with winnable games, a team that lulls you to sleep for three quarters and then hits you in the mouth? No doubt. The Jaguars? Absolutely.
"If you say Jacksonville can't do it, you're not paying attention," Rich said.
The one team that cost itself, in the room's view, was Pittsburgh, which will be lucky to be the seventh seed.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.