Overreaction Monday landed on a Tuesday this week, and Chris Brockman came in hot.
His warmup: when Monday Night Football ended, were Dan Fouts and Kellen Winslow popping champagne because their franchise no longer had to wear the stink of being winless, the way the old Dolphins do? Then the real take.
"The Chargers are going to be sniffing it by Christmas."
Chris's evidence was Justin Herbert running one in on Monday night. "I'm like Rick Dalton GIF, like what, there it is. What happened to that guy?" he said. "This guy has a Josh Allen type game in him. He's big, he's strong, he's big armed. And he creates business decisions when he's running downhill."
Rich, who had just spent an hour predicting a 9-8 finish, defined the terms. "Sniffing it" means appearing on the screen with an outside shot at a wild card. "I think even that's an overreaction, Chris," he said, while admitting to being "a Harbaugh honk" himself.
They mapped out what it would take: wins at home over the Jets and New England, then at Tampa and at Vegas. Rich noted that the entire Northeast would take up residence in SoFi for that Jets game, and that even his brother might be going. If the Chargers get to 5-8 and then beat the Niners at 6-8, "now we're talking." For now, still an overreaction.
Chris's next one: the Seahawks have a quarterback problem and should ride Drew Lock.
"There's no problem," Rich said, several times. "The problem would be if Drew Lock performed like Tommy DeVito did in Munich," or like Cooper Rush in the first two weeks of the season for Atlanta, or like Jacoby Brissett looked in the first quarter on Monday night. "Drew Lock's doing his job. So what's the problem?"
Rich admitted he had been thinking about it in the middle of the night. His rule is to always back the quarterback with a proven track record over a backup doing his job, however good the backup looks. Then he asked himself what he would have said if the show had been on the air in 2001, when Tom Brady was a backup. His answer: that was an outlier. Drew Bledsoe did take that team to a Super Bowl and signed a nine-figure contract. And, "with all due respect," there is a reason Lock's current three-game win streak as a starter is the first of his career.
Overreaction.
Chris then said the Aidan Hutchinson injury combined with Detroit's schedule will keep the Lions out of the playoffs. Rich shared the concern. Losing two terrific players and leaders, Hutchinson and Jack Campbell, could leave the defense badly depleted, while the Rams and Seahawks sit at 6-4 on their byes and "aren't going anywhere." But saying it this definitively right now? Overreaction.
Next, Chris said that if Brock Purdy or Kyle Shanahan does not win hardware this year, they never will. His argument: "This is the best they've looked," and things do not just keep getting better.
Rich called it absurd. The only way it holds, he said, is if Purdy is suspended for life and Shanahan decides real estate sounds good. "Nonsense."
Chris predicted Sunday night's Vikings and Niners game in Mexico City is a preview of the NFC Championship Game. Rich did not call that an overreaction, and took the moment to explain why Chris is so good at this segment. "Overreaction Monday is always in a silo," Rich said. "Each episode, each segment is its own entity." That is how Chris can declare the Bears the team to beat one week and forget they exist the next.
"Mendoza Mania, baby." Chris said Fernando Mendoza will get the Raiders over .500 and win rookie of the year. The room ran through the field: Denzel Boston, KC Concepcion, Jeremiah Love, Jadarian Price with his first touchdown, Carnell Tate, Sonny Styles. "It's not like the field is cluttered," came the observation. Rich mostly wanted to hug Mendoza and give him a glass of milk.
Chris closed with college football. In honor of the last year of conference championship games, someone who loses one will win the national title. Rich did not think that was an overreaction, and went further: the loser of the SEC title game will at least reach the national championship game, because "it means more and it's been a while for them."
Chris wondered if the Big Ten has any good teams. Rich warned that a team in Westwood is about to go to his alma mater and teach a lesson, a team that went to Oregon and won. Then there's Indiana.
Rich had a theory about Chris's SEC loyalty. "He marries somebody who roots for Georgia and all of a sudden this guy."
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.