Friday's What's More Likely had division math, a Kirk Cousins MVP debate, a Chuba Hubbard appreciation moment and, because it was November 20, a trip back to the most chaotic finish in college football history. Chris Brockman ran the board. Rich made the calls.
First question: which division is more likely to put two teams in the playoffs, the AFC South or the NFC East?
Rich needed a second to decode it. On the NFC East side, it's really asking whether the Cowboys and Giants are both good enough to reach nine or 10 wins. The answer leaned AFC South, then flipped. "Texans got to get past the Browns, man. They just lost to the Browns." If Houston had won that game, the AFC South would have been an easy call. Instead, NFC East.
With a couple of huge lines on the board, Brockman asked which big underdog keeps it closest: the Cardinals or the Dolphins. Rich went Dolphins without hesitating. Carson Beck just faced the Rams defense, and now comes a Chiefs defense that "isn't too far off." Plus Miami is a division opponent, and even with different staffs, that still matters.
Which three-win NFC South team plays spoiler against the NFC North, the Saints against Chicago or the Bucs? Rich took the Bucs, whether or not Baker Mayfield plays. Tampa is off a bye, as are the Bears, and Rich thinks Detroit's injuries will catch up eventually. "No Aidan Hutchinson and no Jack Campbell is going to have a residual effect at some point," he said. "The question is how fast."
The Cowboys put up around 40 last week against a defense that, as the crew noted, is now without Jeffery Simmons and Amani Hooker. More points in week 10 or week 11? The table went back and forth before landing on a prediction that this one will be a shootout. Somebody floated 43-38, and the "over hammer" was declared.
Brockman wanted to give some flowers. Both Derrick Henry and Chuba Hubbard have three games this season with at least two touchdowns. Who's more likely to do it this week?
"No one's talking about how great of a season he's had," Rich said of Hubbard, and took him. On Henry, Rich isn't sure what's wrong, whether it's the offensive line, or that the run game was built off a mobile quarterback who isn't there anymore, which leaves fewer chances for Henry to be Henry. The third option, diminishing returns, he still doesn't believe. Someone threw Tony Pollard into the mix, and Rich conceded he might have a big game on Sunday too. Still Chuba.
Which AFC West quarterback runs for more yards in Denver, Fernando Mendoza or Bo Nix? Rich went Bo.
Then the MVP question: who throws more touchdown passes without an interception, Kirk Cousins or Brock Purdy? Rich pushed back on the premise first. "Purdy is an MVP candidate. Cousins is not there yet," he said. He was ready to take Cousins, then reversed to connect it with his Higher Register take that the 49ers offense is in for a big one. Purdy it was. Someone pointed out that Cousins threw one right to the Niners last time he faced them, two weeks ago. Another fun fact: Cousins won't have a bye week this year, since the Raiders' bye is next week and the Vikings' bye came earlier this year. He'll play 18 games.
Which team ends week 11 on a two-game winning streak, the Chargers or the Commanders? "Chargers. Come on," Rich said. The Chargers have a two-win Jets team at home. The Commanders get the "rampaging Bengals" on Monday night. Rich did wonder if SoFi would turn into a Jets crowd.
Brockman's last one honored an anniversary: the 44th anniversary of the day the band came out onto the field. Which was the craziest college football ending of all time, The Band, the Auburn Kick Six or Kordell Stewart's Hail Mary?
Rich was certain Kordell was there just to troll him. The Hail Mary was amazing, he said, but we've seen Hail Marys. We've seen field goals returned for touchdowns. "There was a band on the field, Chris." Players ran through trombone players. "We haven't seen it before and we haven't seen it since and we will never see it again."
Rich added one more detail he was reminded of after seeing "Mr. Irrelevant" this week: John Elway and John Tuggle, the first and last picks of the following draft, played in that game for Stanford and Cal. That, he said, you'll never see again either.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.