Higher Register is supposed to be where The Rich Eisen Show crew goes out on a limb. This week, a couple of the limbs were pretty close to the trunk.
Chris Brockman went first, and he went with the hottest name of the week. "Mendoza Mania. It's Fernando season in Las Vegas."
The conventional wisdom, Chris said, is that Fernando Mendoza will have a rough go out of the gate because of the schedule. Chris is not buying it. His comparison was a Seahawks matchup that went very differently for two quarterbacks. "I think Fernando's going to look more like Caleb against Seahawks than Mahomes did," he said. "Mahomes got wrecked by the Seahawks and Caleb kind of dominated. I think it's going to be closer to Caleb."
Rich summed it up: the needle points more Caleb than Mahomes.
TJ Jefferson went to the trade deadline. The Colts, TJ said, were widely seen as a team waving the white flag, and Jonathan Taylor's name was being thrown around everywhere. Nobody got him. "The Colts held on to Jonathan Taylor. And to be honest, I kind of think they did the right thing."
TJ's reasoning was about the fans. "You got to give them something to believe in, right? You give up Taylor, there is no hope. There's no reason for them to show up the rest of the season." He compared it to baseball teams that throw in the towel mid-season and sell off their players, which has always struck him as strange. The Colts, he argued, are thinking about the future. The studio's addendum: if you are not getting a first-round pick, keep him. "He's too good."
Then came the turn to Dallas, delivered with what the crew dubbed a "double T," a troll and a transition. The setup was that the Colts can't have been waving the white flag that hard, because they almost beat the Cowboys. And now the narrative is that Dallas barely beat a surrendering team and here come the 49ers for a total wipeout.
The take went the other way. "I kind of think this Niners-Cowboys game is going to be like one of those old school classics. Another chapter in this long-standing rivalry." The hope was for two teams trading blows, with the defense showing up on both sides. "I'm not saying that Dallas is going to win. I'm just saying they're going to show up in a way that we haven't seen them show up in that building against this team that has their number."
That was not the end of it. A second, "double register" followed, the kind the panel itself admitted was ridiculous: "If the Cowboys do find a way to get over this hurdle that I said they can't get over of the San Francisco 49ers, I think we might go to the Super Bowl."
The room exploded. "Sometimes you just got to give the people what they want."
Then came the critique from the desk. Chris did not really have to take a stand, since Mendoza looking more like a quarterback who played well than one who got wrecked is a soft landing. The Cowboys take was the same: predict a close, old-school game and never say who wins.
The response was pure Cowboys fan logic. "I'm going to get hated on anyways, a Cowboys fan, so let's give them something to really hate."
So the Week 10 Higher Register ended with one bold Super Bowl claim, two safe-ish predictions and a defense of the Colts. Tepid takes, as advertised.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.