NFL Week 10: Cousins, Burrow, JSN, Cowboys & More | Overreaction Monday wRich Eisen & Chris Brockman
Watch on YouTube 40:57

NFL Week 10: Cousins, Burrow, JSN, Cowboys & More | Overreaction Monday wRich Eisen & Chris Brockman

Overreaction Monday opened with Rich asking Chris Brockman a simple question: did he need a hug?

Chris, a Patriots fan, had woken up early on the West Coast for the 6:30 a.m. Pacific kickoff in Munich, watched Drake Maye march New England down to the two-yard line on the opening drive, saw Will Campbell draw a penalty at a huge spot, "and then two plays later, season's over." Chris didn't argue. "It's completely over," he said. Rich's summary: "Worst trip to Germany since Stripes."

From there, Chris ran through his week 10 takes, and Rich ruled on each one.

Chris's first take: Kirk Cousins plus this Vikings defense equals Minnesota is the team to beat in the NFC.

Chris skipped Sunday night to start at Lambeau Field, and Rich's first response was a question: did he see what the Niners did in Dallas? The beauty, Rich said, is that both of them will get their answer in week 11, when the 8-1 49ers and the Vikings meet in Mexico City.

Rich gave Minnesota its due. Cousins, in his first game in purple since he blew out his Achilles on that same Lambeau field, "looked like he'd never left." He found receivers "whose names you never even heard of," and Justin Jefferson posted a season-high nine receptions, without Jordan Addison or Hockenson. "It's not just 18 playing football still," Rich said, "but 18 looking like 18." Both running backs did their thing, and the defense lived on Jordan Love. The viral still photo showed every member of the Vikings' front behind the Packers' offensive line right after the snap. It brought back Green Bay's early-season problems: can't run it, can't block it, and on occasion Matthew Golden can't catch it. Love was sacked eight times, the first Packer to take eight at Lambeau since Bart Starr in the Ice Bowl.

"That went as well as anyone could have possibly imagined," Rich agreed. "But the Niners are still the team to beat in the NFC." He called it an overreaction for now, partly because the Bears were sitting at home on their bye. "Bye-week teams we don't think about," Rich said. "They don't exist."

Next take: The Bengals are the real deal, and they're going to be the one seed in the AFC.

Rich noted the real deal may have been in Dallas, where Christian McCaffrey did something unprecedented. But Joe Burrow is "lights out." Before the season Burrow said the offense reminded him of his LSU year, when he threw 60 touchdown passes, and he's on his way. He now has five straight games accounting for at least four touchdowns, tying Peyton Manning's 2004 MVP season for the longest streak in NFL history. His fifth career game with 400 passing yards and four touchdowns tied Mahomes and Drew Brees for third most ever.

Rich recalled Rod Woodson once telling him there's no more reactive organism than an NFL defense. "At one point it did not look like the Steelers were playing defense 11 on 11." He also reminded Chris that he had picked the Bengals as his number one sleeper team, meaning a sleeper Super Bowl favorite, and the defense just wiped the Steelers off the field when "nobody thought the Bengals defense could wipe anybody anywhere at any time."

Next up: Washington on a Monday night, home for New Orleans, two against Cleveland, and Kansas City. Cincinnati doesn't face Denver or Buffalo, though Rich expects to see both in the playoffs. The question is whether the Bengals can catch the Bills, and conference record would be the tiebreaker. Buffalo's remaining schedule is tougher: Kansas City at home on Thanksgiving night, at Green Bay on a Sunday night, Chicago at home and at Denver. "Cincinnati has an easier schedule," Rich said, "and, I can't believe I'm saying this, hotter quarterback." He wouldn't yet say better defense, with Buffalo improving and Amani Hooker now on the back end. Verdict: not an overreaction. "But the Niners still lurk."

Then Pittsburgh: The Steelers have been fugazi this whole time and are destined for another one and done.

Rich called it an overreaction, but conceded Pittsburgh will likely have to go on the road in the playoffs, possibly to Kansas City or Denver as a loaded four seed. He couldn't say they've been fugazi all along, though Pittsburgh "got totally exposed" offensively and couldn't touch Burrow. The broadcast noted the Steelers never landed a receiver at the deadline, and the table wondered what happened to DK Metcalf, even if Rodgers found him late. The table likened that to an A-Rod solo homer in the ninth with the Yankees down 8-1.

On to the AFC wild card: With the Patriots and Texans seemingly cooked, the Browns are going to be the final AFC playoff team.

"I don't disagree," Rich said. He walked through it: Deshaun Watson was considered unplayable in Cleveland, struggled in the preseason against Buffalo's third-stringers, got booed and clapped back, and Monken started him anyway. Cleveland lost in Jacksonville, beat Baker Mayfield in Tampa, then beat Carolina, Pittsburgh on a Thursday night and Baltimore, and now Houston after falling behind by two scores. They're 4-0 at home for the first time since 1963.

Rich did caution against writing off Baltimore, recording before Jacoby Brissett's first start as a Raven. Brissett is a bona fide veteran starter (Rich refused to use the word "solid," which he considers an insult), he can put the ball in Zay Flowers' hands, and the Ravens close with four division games. Rich also noted Fernando Mendoza became the first number one overall pick in the common draft era to score a scrimmage touchdown on his first drive of his first start. But for now, "the Browns have the leg up."

Then Seattle: Jaxon Smith-Njigba will be the first repeat Offensive Player of the Year since Marshall Faulk in 2000.

No pushback. JSN is the fourth player in NFL history with 1,200 or more receiving yards and 10 or more receiving touchdowns through his first 10 games; the others are Raymond Berry, Elroy "Crazylegs" Hirsch and Don Hutson, all Hall of Famers. Rich drew the line at a post calling JSN the best receiver of all time. "There's Jerry Rice, for crying out loud." But JSN has eight 100-yard games, tied for the most through 10 games in league history, and more receiving yards than the rest of the Seahawks combined. "Every defense knows you're looking for him," Rich said. "And he still does it." Rich called it "100% proper." Chris saved his Drew Lock take for Tuesday, but took a shot at Mike Tomlin's quarterback advice anyway.

Then Dallas: The Cowboys should have done literally anything at the trade deadline.

Rich pushed back. Dallas traded for Joey Porter a month before the deadline, and had already added Rashan Gary next to Kenny Clark and Quinnen Williams, with Daron Bland and Caleb Downs in the secondary. Chris argued they should have flipped Pickens for a defender; the counter was that Pickens is what kept them in a game they led 16-10 after Brandon Aubrey missed an extra point, before the roof caved in. The numbers were brutal: 584 yards allowed, the most in a home game in franchise history, and a third straight season at 4-6. The defensive tackles clearly aren't good enough, which puts it on the scheme and the coaches, who might be gone. Chris wondered how much longer Dak wants to do this with the Cowboys. The answer from across the table: as long as the owner wants to pay him $60 million.

Rich also ran through McCaffrey's day: 161 receiving yards on four catches, the most by a running back since Jamaal Charles 13 years ago, and eight straight games with a rushing touchdown, breaking Joe Perry's franchise mark. He and Deebo Samuel became the first pair of 49ers teammates since the 1970 merger to each have a rushing and receiving touchdown in the same game. "When this guy goes into the Hall of Fame," Rich said, these are the plays you'll see.

On the NFC playoff picture: Only one of the Packers, Rams and Seahawks will make the playoffs.

With three 7-2 teams in the NFC North, Chris figured only one of those three gets in. Rich called it an overreaction and named the 7-2 team he'd worry about: Detroit, now without Aidan Hutchinson and Jack Campbell, "two lionhearted major pieces," with a tough schedule ahead. Rich's guess for the two wild cards from that group: Rams and Seahawks, which makes the post-bye Rams-Packers game huge.

And Kansas City: Josh Downs is the missing piece that unlocked the Chiefs' offense.

Rich saw a deep roster instead. Rookie Emmett Johnson became the first Chiefs rookie with 150 scrimmage yards and two touchdowns since Kareem Hunt in 2017, and Mahomes threw three touchdowns of 15-plus air yards after having none in his first eight games. "So Josh Downs helps," Rich said. "I don't know if he's the missing piece."

The tweet of the week said only seven teams can win it all: Niners, Bears, Vikings, Bills, Bengals, Chiefs and Jaguars. Rich objected immediately. "Where are the Broncos?" He wasn't discounting the defending champion Seahawks, the Rams, who have won four straight, or Denver either. The debate turned into a draft. Rich handed Chris every team on the list except the Niners and the Bengals, then made it official: his Super Bowl 61 redo is Niners versus Bengals. Chris went with Jaguars versus Bears, which Rich agreed would be a fun one.

Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
Segment
In This Interview
Are the Kirk Cousins Led Vikings the FAVORITES In the NFC?!
Are the Kirk Cousins Led Vikings the FAVORITES In the NFC?!
Related Clips
A Vacation to Barbados with Red Sox P Payton Tolle Sounds Like a BLAST!!! | The Rich Eisen Show
A Vacation to Barbados with Red Sox P Payton Tolle Sounds Like a BLAST!!! | The Rich Eisen Show
What’s More Likely: Rich Talks 49ers-Vikings, Raiders-Broncos, Cowboys, Chargers & More!
What’s More Likely: Rich Talks 49ers-Vikings, Raiders-Broncos, Cowboys, Chargers & More!
NFL Week 11 ‘Higher Register’ – 49ers, Cowboys & Raiders Tepid Takes | The Rich Eisen Show
NFL Week 11 ‘Higher Register’ – 49ers, Cowboys & Raiders Tepid Takes | The Rich Eisen Show