ESPN’s Josh Pate Talks CFP Expansion & Rankings and Michigan’s Mess with Rich Eisen | Full Interview
Watch on YouTube 17:01

ESPN’s Josh Pate Talks CFP Expansion & Rankings and Michigan’s Mess with Rich

Josh Pate does not like where college football is headed, and he wants everyone to stop blaming ESPN for it. He also thinks Rich's alma mater should move on from its head coach, and he didn't soften that one bit when Rich pushed back.

The opening was lighter. John Travolta was up next on the show, and Pate admitted he once snuck a copy of Grease on VHS as a kid. His defense to his mother: "It's PG. Why in the world is it a problem that I have this?"

**The 24-team playoff: blame the coaches, not ESPN**

Then Rich got to the news of the week. The College Football Playoff is officially expanding to 24 teams next year, with the presenters putting up $1.7 billion to make it happen.

"Not the biggest fan," Pate said. "I am a big, big proponent of our most valuable commodity, which is the regular season in college football."

He tunes out comparisons to the NFL or college basketball. "This sport, college football, is my favorite. I think it's the best sport on the planet, but I also think it's one of one." And he called out what he sees as the central myth of expansion. "One of the biggest lies is you create more meaningful games, which is not true," Pate said. "It just kind of redirects value off of games featuring better teams and puts it on games featuring average teams."

The other big lie, he said, is that this is ESPN's doing. "It's very unpopular to defend ESPN in the college football streets these days," Pate admitted. "But it is just mere truth when I tell you the bad guy here, if you're against this like I am, it's not necessarily ESPN. Those folks would have just as soon had this thing stay at 12."

The push, as Pate described it, came from below: coaches who pushed athletic directors, who pushed presidents, who pushed commissioners. Once they were all on board, ESPN's move was to make sure it owned the whole thing. "That's how anyone would have operated."

Pate also took apart the argument that expansion was the price of better scheduling or better guardrails. "You could do that anyway. You guys could do that right now." Moments after the expansion news broke, he noted, the next headline he saw was Florida and Notre Dame canceling a future home-and-home.

**A "college football new deal"?**

Pate's bigger prediction concerned what comes after this deal expires in four or five years. He thinks the landscape will be "radically different." Conferences already mean less than they used to, and he's hearing rumblings that independence "may not just be Notre Dame down the road."

"Is this just the new normal, or is this the death rattle of the old way of doing things?" Pate asked, floating what he called, for lack of a better phrase, "a college football new deal."

Rich liked where that was going. If the death of conferences meant fairer scheduling and guardrails, including ones that keep coaches from simply being bought out, then sign him up. But every New Deal needs an FDR. Who would it be?

"I'll do it," Pate said. "I don't care. I'll do it." Rich pledged his support for the candidacy.

**The latest CFP rankings: Indiana's drop and Georgia's shelf**

On the latest playoff rankings, Pate wasn't shocked that Indiana dropped. The issue, beyond an untimely bye, was that "while they sat at home, everyone else they had played lost." He understands why casual fans looked at that and wondered how a team falls five spots without playing, but he said it's a byproduct of resumes being judged in totality every week.

He also pointed out how strange this season's picture is. "The Big Ten's main hopes are Indiana and UCLA," he said, while the Big 12 has four teams in roughly the top 14. After Indiana and UCLA, it's Oregon and USC, three West Coast teams and an Indiana program that would have been the least likely Big Ten contender "up until five minutes ago."

Pate warned that people have the marquee games memorized but not the full schedules. Tennessee has LSU, but first it's a two-and-a-half-point favorite at Texas A&M. Utah has to go to Tucson. Texas Tech has to get past Oklahoma State.

And then there's Georgia. "Georgia looks like the North Star right now. Georgia looks like the constant," Pate said. "They're the one team you can set your watch to." But the road isn't easy, with a desperate Missouri team and a trip to South Carolina, which still has playoff life. "One Georgia loss throws everything into a blender... Georgia could be drug right back into that if they're not careful."

**Michigan should move on from Kyle Whittingham**

Then Rich got personal. Pate's comments about Michigan and Kyle Whittingham had circulated in Rich's Michigan community. Did Pate really think it's over, a failed experiment?

Pate went further. Someone usually privy to coaching-world information told him he expects Whittingham back next year. "I'm saying there's 0% chance I see him there next year," Pate said.

He stressed that he's the last guy to call for someone's job and rarely touches hot-seat talk. That's why this landed so hard. He called Whittingham a legend for what he did at Utah. But on Michigan: "I feel like I'm opening the fridge and I'm looking at the milk carton and it says November 6th on it. It's not going to unexpire. It's done. It's spoiled."

His comparison point was Ryan Silverfield, struggling in year one at Arkansas. Pate isn't calling for that job, because there are signs Silverfield is bought in and the roster will fight for him. "I don't see any of that at Michigan," he said. If Michigan competes at Oregon this weekend, Pate would credit the players "almost in spite of what's happening around them." And he can't find anyone willing to put their name behind Whittingham.

What really rubbed him the wrong way was Whittingham bristling at the program's traditions and trophy games while being paid $8 million a year. "If memorizing the names of trophy games turns you off, if you think you're above that, okay, maybe you're above it, but don't take the job," Pate said. He compared it to Lincoln taking the USC job and then not wanting to play Notre Dame. "If you take the Michigan job, you're signing up to be part of all that stuff. You don't exist there in spite of it. You exist there with it."

Rich found it hard to argue. The most puzzling part of Whittingham's tenure, Rich said, is his distance from the tradition, especially after losing the jug and the axe to Minnesota and Michigan State and then saying he didn't think there were any more trophy games left. "It did land as a thud in the Michigan football world," Rich said. He contrasted it with Pat Fitzgerald, a Northwestern guy, who "owned the rivalry like he's been there his entire life" at Michigan State.

Still, Rich wouldn't be surprised if Whittingham stays. Michigan needs a new athletic director, and the new president starts at the end of December. Rich also noted that somebody had to green-light, or "maize and blue light," paying off the most expensive offensive coordinator's salary.

Pate's counter was about the roster. Even if Whittingham is retained, Pate is hard pressed to believe most of the roster sticks around, or that top portal players are circling Ann Arbor. "There's no rebuild year anymore. You're supposed to compete for the Big Ten and be in the playoff every year," he said. "I know it sucks to pay people not to coach, but sometimes you got to do it."

Rich signed off hoping to share more positive Michigan videos with his friends soon. Pate's reply: "We'll smile next week."

Watch the full interview with Josh Pate on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
People
Segment
In This Interview
Josh Pate: Blame Coaches & AD’s, Not ESPN, for the CFP Expanding to 24 Teams | The Rich Eisen Show
Josh Pate: Blame Coaches & AD’s, Not ESPN, for the CFP Expanding to 24 Teams | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate: Why Michigan Should Part Ways with Kyle Whittingham | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate: Why Michigan Should Part Ways with Kyle Whittingham | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate Breaks Down the Latest College Football Playoff Rankings | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate Breaks Down the Latest College Football Playoff Rankings | The Rich Eisen Show
Related Clips
ESPN’s Josh Pate Breaks Down the Top “Do-Not-Lose-Again” CFP Bubble Teams | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate Breaks Down the Top “Do-Not-Lose-Again” CFP Bubble Teams | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate Talks CFP Rankings, Dabo Hot Seat, Michigan & More with Rich | Full Interview
ESPN’s Josh Pate Talks CFP Rankings, Dabo Hot Seat, Michigan & More with Rich | Full Interview
ESPN’s Josh Pate: The CFP Selection Committee’s Love of the SEC is Warranted | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate: The CFP Selection Committee’s Love of the SEC is Warranted | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate: What Michigan’s New AD Hire Means for Kyle Whittingham | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate: What Michigan’s New AD Hire Means for Kyle Whittingham | The Rich Eisen Show