ESPN’s Josh Pate: What Michigan’s New AD Hire Means for Kyle Whittingham | The Rich Eisen Show
Watch on YouTube 2:59

ESPN’s Josh Pate: What Michigan’s New AD Hire Means for Kyle Whittingham

Part of the full interview: ESPN’s Josh Pate Talks CFP Rankings, Dabo Hot Seat, Michigan & More with Rich Eisen | Full Interview

Josh Pate called in from a park in Nashville, soaking up 73 degrees before a trip to Bozeman, Montana, and spent the next several minutes cutting through the three biggest storylines in college football: Michigan's new athletic director, the mess at Clemson and a College Football Playoff committee that, in his view, has fallen in love with Alabama.

Rich went first, and he went straight to Michigan. What does Pate make of Michigan hiring Trev Alberts as athletic director?

"Great reputation," Pate said. "Everybody thinks the world of him." His first reaction, though, was for Texas A&M fans, who have now watched Ohio State and Michigan hire away their athletic directors back to back. Pate said that isn't automatically a sign something is wrong in College Station. Guys leave for two of the most prestigious jobs in college football.

Rich politely made clear he cared about Michigan, not the 12th Man. So what does the hire signal about what Alberts will do once he has boots on the ground in Ann Arbor?

"I think he'll want his own guy," Pate said. "Certainly not Kyle Whittingham." He said the coaching market is waiting on two potential moves, Michigan and Clemson, and he thinks the Michigan one will happen.

Pate walked through the logic in parts. Part one: is what's happening now going to work? Most people say no. Part two: do you make a move? Part three, which depends on part two: doesn't any viable candidate want to see structural integrity, starting with an athletic director in place? That musical chairs, he said, ends now. The last question is how many coaches want to work with Alberts, and given his reputation, Pate couldn't imagine a viable candidate saying no. Michigan also has what Alberts understands as weapons: a place in one of the premier conferences in the sport and a war chest. "It's not a guarantee you're going to move," Pate said, "but if you don't move now, we know it won't be because you didn't fill that chair."

That brought up Clemson and Dabo Swinney, and Pate didn't soften it. "It's so ugly. It's so messy. Dabo seems really dug in."

He said he has always been conflicted about Swinney, because he respects anyone who defines their principles and sticks to them, even when it's unpopular. The problem, Pate said, is that Swinney is "very much married to the past, unwilling to lean into the future." And it isn't ignorance. "It's not that he doesn't see it," Pate said. "He is willingly not leaning into it." The transfer portal is the talent acquisition mechanism everyone else is using, and Clemson has only dabbled.

Pate pointed to a recent press conference where Swinney noted Clemson has won two national titles in the past decade, averaging one every five years. Technically true, Pate said, but those titles came in 2016 and 2018, and the world has changed even in the last four years. Clemson had three home losses in the past decade and has three this season alone. Georgia Tech dominated them. Clemson passed on getting a quarterback from the portal when it had the money, stuck with Chris Vizzina, benched him, lost the backup to injury and had to put Vizzina back in.

"Everything that he tried doing it his way in the modern time has failed to produce results," Pate said. The number Clemson is looking at, he said, is 57 million, and he thinks the school is hoping Swinney knocks on the door and offers to negotiate. People with guaranteed money rarely give it up voluntarily. Pate imagined meetings where Swinney's few bosses tell him what he has to do and he answers, "No, I don't have to do anything. And if you don't like that, fire me. And if you fire me, that's how much you owe me."

Then the committee. Rich asked what message the latest week 12 rankings were sending.

"Well, they really love Alabama," Pate said. They don't seem nearly as keen on Tennessee. The overarching message is love for the SEC, and Pate said that part is excusable because the SEC has been the best league in the country. He largely agrees with the four-loss SEC teams sitting in the 20 to 25 range, not because those teams are special, but because you run out of viable options. Liberty is undefeated, he acknowledged, but hasn't played a top 60 team, and someone in the oddsmaking community told him Arkansas would probably be favored to go undefeated against Liberty's schedule.

Critics who say South Carolina, Oklahoma or Florida don't belong, Pate said, need to tell him who does. "What it boils down to is feelings," he said. "Those aren't data points." If the committee says it values conference strength and strength of schedule, then those SEC teams make sense.

What doesn't make sense to him is Alabama at three. Listening to the committee's explanation, Pate said, he heard logic meant "to reverse engineer a conclusion they had already arrived at," cherry picking criteria to keep Alabama high. He doesn't care about the room's football judgment, he said, because coaches are as bad at predicting games as anyone. Former coaches and players in media don't run circles around everyone at picking games, and fired coaches don't go get rich betting football. "What I care about is evenly applied criteria," he said. Evenly applied, he thinks Texas would be above Alabama and Alabama and Tennessee would be close enough for head-to-head to matter. And the people saying it will all sort itself out should note that there are only two weeks of regular season games left.

So who is the committee telling not to lose again? Pate couldn't tell what it is saying to Indiana, which keeps getting penciled into the Big Ten Championship game, including by him. The Hoosiers go to Washington as seven and a half point road favorites, and their last two big road trips were an overtime game at Michigan and a fourth quarter double digit deficit at Nebraska. They only need to win, even by one, but a loss would leave them in uneasy territory.

Wake Forest, he thinks, is being told it has to win its conference to get in, and he expected Wake to be higher than 11. Tennessee faces LSU this weekend with LSU favored, which has blown people's minds. Pate also noted the scheduling quirk hurting the Vols: Tennessee keeps playing teams right after Alabama does, A&M, then Vanderbilt, now LSU, and Alabama's wins keep devaluing those opponents before Tennessee gets its shot. LSU isn't even ranked now, so a win won't springboard Tennessee much, but a loss will drop them.

And BYU, he said, feels like it is just floating there after being boxed out last year. If Oregon or Ohio State stumble or Texas Tech climbs, Pate could easily see BYU on the chopping block again, and he said it would be BYU's own fault after losing at UCF a couple of weeks ago. "You cannot do that."

Watch the full interview with Josh Pate on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
People
Segment
Related Clips
ESPN’s Josh Pate Breaks Down the Top “Do-Not-Lose-Again” CFP Bubble Teams | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate Breaks Down the Top “Do-Not-Lose-Again” CFP Bubble Teams | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate Talks CFP Rankings, Dabo Hot Seat, Michigan & More with Rich | Full Interview
ESPN’s Josh Pate Talks CFP Rankings, Dabo Hot Seat, Michigan & More with Rich | Full Interview
ESPN’s Josh Pate: The CFP Selection Committee’s Love of the SEC is Warranted | The Rich Eisen Show
ESPN’s Josh Pate: The CFP Selection Committee’s Love of the SEC is Warranted | The Rich Eisen Show
Needless to Say It’s Been a Heckuva 12-Months for NC State HC Philip Rivers | The Rich Eisen Show
Needless to Say It’s Been a Heckuva 12-Months for NC State HC Philip Rivers | The Rich Eisen Show