Ten weeks into the season, Rich is ready to use his mulligan.
One week from Thursday, he'll be on NFL Network's NFL GameDay Morning pregame show for the Thanksgiving tripleheader, where he gets a chance to redo his preseason Super Bowl 61 pick. Before the season he went Bills versus Rams. If he had to place his finger on the mulligan right now, the new pick is Bengals versus 49ers at SoFi Stadium.
"Good old school '80s matchup," came the reply from across the table.
Rich didn't make the call lightly. Buffalo is 8-1 behind Josh Allen and is still undefeated on the road, a game ahead of a Bengals team it doesn't play this year. Cincinnati doesn't play the Broncos either, barring a playoff meeting. Denver, Kansas City and Jacksonville are all 7-2. Whoever ends up as the five seed after missing out on a division title, Rich said, is going to have to visit "one heck of a seed."
So why Cincinnati? Yes, Joe Burrow is the MVP frontrunner through 10 weeks. Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins are "playing out of their skulls," and Chase Brown had a couple of touchdowns. But for Rich, the difference is two things nobody could say about the Burrow Bengals since their Super Bowl season.
The first is protection. Even during that Super Bowl run, the question was whether they could keep Burrow upright, and they couldn't when Aaron Donald took over at the end of that game. Against the Steelers, Burrow "looked like he was having a ham sandwich back there before he chose which wide open receiver to throw to."
The second is the defense, which Rich called "1,000% improved." A 6-2 Steelers team came in with an offense built around the running back and Jaylen Warren, and the Bengals "just erased them. Erased them."
Burrow's line: 409 passing yards, four touchdowns, 34 of 44 for 79.5 percent. It was his fifth straight game accounting for at least four touchdowns, tying Peyton Manning for the longest streak in NFL history. Manning was MVP the season he did it, 2004.
Zac Taylor, who Rich noted is on the hot seat no more, didn't hold back either. "It'd be impossible to say anybody's playing better than him," Taylor said. "If you are watching all of our games, it's really hard to say that this dude's not the best player on planet Earth."
Rich kept going with the numbers. Burrow's fifth career game with 400 passing yards and four touchdowns ties Mahomes and Brees for third most in NFL history, behind Marino and Peyton Manning. His 30 passing and rushing touchdowns through nine games are six more than any other player this season, tied for the fifth most by any player in his team's first nine games. Each of the previous five to do it won MVP. The Steelers blitzed him 13 times, and he completed 13 passes for 190 yards against it, the most attempts without an interception against the blitz since ESPN began tracking in 2006. He had 300 passing yards and three touchdowns by halftime.
Before the season, Burrow said this offense reminded him of his LSU offense. That LSU team had Chase and Justin Jefferson, and Burrow threw 60 touchdowns. He has 30 now. Halfway there.
Rich workshopped a nickname, "Joe Stradamus," which got the table's approval. Burrow, asked what now at the halfway point, kept it level. "It's week nine," he said. "So we got a lot of football to be played. Learn from my mistakes, celebrate the win, but come back to be better."
The postgame look got its own review. With the cowlick, glasses and that shirt, Rich said, Burrow looked like Clark Kent, or "a New England liberal arts English teacher." The table wondered what his office hours are.
The schedule ahead: Washington on Monday night after a mini bye and an extra day of rest, home for the Saints, the big one against Kansas City, then two with Cleveland. Rich warned against discounting the Browns, who are a game behind and have "a resilience that nobody saw coming."
And the trade that may define this season was already being discussed during the Sunday night broadcast. The Bengals flipped the 10th overall pick to the Giants for "Sexy Dexy," the guy in the middle New York didn't think was worth the money, and remade their defense around him. Rich's last checkmark went to defensive coordinator Al Golden.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.