What’s More Likely: Andrew Siciliano Talks Bears, Cowboys, Browns, Dolphins & More

Andrew Siciliano, the radio voice of the Browns now entering his third season, took the floor for a round of What's More Likely, presented by Pella, and his answers ranged from Cleveland's quarterback room to which mascot would scare him most on the Jaws anniversary.

On who starts more games for the Browns, Watson or Sanders, Siciliano went with Shedeur Sanders for the bit, while stressing he genuinely doesn't know the week-one starter and now gives Sanders more of a shot than he did a couple of weeks ago. He laid out a brutal Browns opening, back-to-back road games in Florida at Jacksonville and Tampa, with four of their five games against last year's playoff teams coming in the first five weeks.

Asked which team has the better offense in 2026, Bears or Cowboys, Siciliano took Chicago, betting on a year-two leap from Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams while citing the Cowboys' history of offensive injuries. TJ Jefferson, predictably, took the Cowboys on the strength of the league's best receiver duo, and cheerfully admitted nothing could make him pick the Bears, owning his role as the resident super fan whose offense is great and whose defense merely needs to not stink.

On the rookie quarterbacks, Fernando Mendoza or Brendan Sorsby starting more games, Siciliano picked Mendoza, predicting some kind of suspension for Sorsby and reminding everyone there is no supplemental draft until the league actually grants one, no matter how much the internet debates who picks him.

The lightning round got personal. Guardians winning the American League or Syracuse winning the ACC? Siciliano, a fan of both, took the Guardians, praising a disciplined, well-run organization that keeps winning the AL Central without spending big. Bigger number, miles flown by the 49ers or feet hiked by Siciliano? He conceded the 49ers' 38,000 miles, admitting he's fallen off his hiking and won't get to the Aconcagua climb he wants because its window falls during football season. And on the Jaws anniversary, scariest mascot among sharks, lions, or pirates, Siciliano landed on lions, explaining that mountain lions always see you even when you never see them, while offering that most bears are just big dumb raccoons, except grizzlies, which you lose to every time.