Larry is 43 years old, lives in Seattle, and has been a Jets fan his whole life. He heard Rich refer to the Jets as his "old team" the day before, and he called in with one question.
"Look, I hate this team too, but I love the fans that I suffer with," Larry said. "There's something comforting knowing we're suffering together. And I guess I'm wondering, are you still with us?"
"Oh, I am absolutely not, Larry," Rich said.
The studio reacted like a contract had just been executed. "Sign the document."
Rich explained himself through family. His older brother, Jeffrey Rich, an estate and tax lawyer "to the stars," is the smartest guy he knows, and still lives and dies with this team. Rich watches his brother and is glad he has checked out.
"There are times when I watch the Jets and I'm like, I'm so glad I'm emotionally checked out," Rich said. "I'm numb. I've been hit with Novocain or whatever you want to call it." He compared it to the cocktail of drugs advertised during football games. "It's so much better of a viewing experience, Larry. It really is."
Larry took it in stride, then went high register. "Maybe you could find a way to take me with you?"
The room loved it. "Perfect high register right there," came the verdict. "You get us, Larry."
Rich left a crack in the door. He once said he was completely out on the Knicks, and then a couple of players pulled him back in. What wears on him with the Jets is "week in and week out watching other teams play smart football with their young players or have clock management that outfoxes the other team." He did acknowledge they have a ton of young players and a bunch of draft choices coming.
Larry, also a Knicks fan, summed up his own coping strategy: "One day when it happens, I'm hoping the numb wears off and in the meantime, we win the offseason every year and I have hope for two weeks."
Then Rich realized where Larry was calling from. A Jets fan in Seattle, watching Sam Darnold bring a parade there? "If I was capable of making sensible decisions, I wouldn't be a Jets fan," Larry said. He wore his Jets Darnold jersey to celebrate with the people around him.
Rich pressed. He lives in Los Angeles and has been drawn to the Rams through friends in the front office, a coach like McVay dialing things up, and an owner who lets everyone do their jobs and "knows how to run a sports franchise." Didn't Seattle bring Larry into the tent?
"It did," Larry said. But loyalty is how he was raised. He pointed to Garrett Wilson still being part of the fan base. "It's tough to give up the loyalty. It is nice watching good football sometimes though."
After Larry hung up, Rich considered what it would take to bring him back. "It's going to have to be a quarterback. Like Brunson."
The desk suggested ownership is what is really keeping him out. Rich was careful there, noting that Woody has been generous to the run on occasion over the years. The issue, Rich said, is the team can't "find the right mix, stick with the right mix." He thinks they had the coach right with Robert Saleh, and pointed to the move to Rodgers as the moment it went sideways.
That led to a Larry David story. Rich recalled seeing the Curb Your Enthusiasm episode built around a Jets fan friend in advance, during his years in the edit bay with the show. He sensed Larry David was worried that by the time the episode aired in January, the Jets would finally be good and the storyline would not ring true. Rich's reaction: "I wouldn't be concerned about that."
Asked whether Herm was the Jets' last good coach, Rich pushed back. "Robert Saleh is a good coach, man. Todd Bowles is a good coach, too. They never got the quarterback right. And when the quarterback was right, they didn't stick with him. Or his Achilles popped. It's a quarterback driven league."
Then he cut himself off. Jeremy Fowler was coming up, U2 was coming in Friday, and he was in a good mood. "I don't want to go down this road."
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.