Every year it happens. The most popular player in the NFL, not by name but by position, is the backup quarterback.
Right now that guy is Drew Lock, 3-0 as Seattle's starter. And Rich has noticed what happens when a backup gets hot: people start forgetting who he replaced. He compared it to the flashy wand in Men in Black. Who is the starting quarterback in Seattle again?
"Oh, wait a minute. It's Sam Darnold," Rich said. The guy who took the Seahawks to the Super Bowl last year, and won it. "Oh, there he is holding the trophy."
Rich's position was clear. Darnold is expected back after Seattle's bye, and he should start because he is healthy and he is the Super Bowl winning quarterback. Darnold hurt his glute in the first game, then got hurt again. "And suddenly it's just like, yeah, thanks for the memory, Sam."
He gave Lock full credit. Lock is "making some crazy ass throws," and has won three straight starts for the first time in his career. But that is the job. "Backup quarterbacks are supposed to do what Drew Lock is doing right now," Rich said.
"I'm always going to take the side of the starting quarterback who gets hurt and who has already done a large body of work," he said. "I understand it's just one year in Seattle, but check the box, man, and check the trophy case before you, and then check yourself."
Not everyone agreed. The pushback: the offense has run better with Lock, mainly because he has not been turning it over. One guy has zero turnovers, the other has nine.
Rich went after the logic. Wasn't the narrative that Seattle's offense is all Jaxon Smith-Njigba and nothing else? Smith-Njigba has eight games with 100 receiving yards, and Lock has only played in four. Smith-Njigba has 1,207 receiving yards, more than the rest of the team combined at 1,122.
The difference now, Rich said, is a run game that was missing earlier in the year when Darnold was playing. Zach Charbonnet just had a season-high 94 rushing yards. And the reason Seattle has four losses, he argued, is not solely the quarterback. The defense has been less consistent too. "Caleb Williams, that was Sam Darnold's fault. Okay," he said, dripping with sarcasm.
Rich would rather spend the energy on Smith-Njigba as an MVP conversation. The desk called him almost a lock for offensive player of the year, with Jahmyr Gibbs the only one who could run him down.
The numbers are historic. Eight 100-yard games ties the most through 10 games in NFL history. And he is the fourth player ever with 1,200 or more receiving yards and 10 or more receiving touchdowns in the first 10 games of a season. The others: Raymond Berry, Crazylegs Hirsch and Don Hutson, all Hall of Famers.
Mike Macdonald settled the question on the radio Monday. "I'd say we're really optimistic that he's going to be able to get a full week's worth of work and be able to play against San Francisco," he said, adding there are still hurdles to clear. Asked if Darnold would start if he clears them: "Drew's been fantastic. He's been phenomenal, but Sam's our quarterback."
The room noticed Macdonald chuckled.
The follow-up hypothetical from the desk: what if Darnold comes back and Seattle gets blasted by the 49ers, with Darnold throwing three interceptions? Rich would not entertain it. "The guy won the Super Bowl last year and the locker room probably loves him and I don't think he's going to play that way."
He has seen this movie before. Mac Jones was supposed to supplant Brock Purdy last year, and look at what Purdy is doing now. Cooper Rush over Dak was another one. "We've seen backup quarterbacks come in, do their jobs, which is their job."
The stakes are real. Seattle and the Rams are both 6-4 and on a bye, and Rich thinks it is unlikely both make it with the NFC North stacked. The Packers, in last place in that division, would be in first in two other divisions.
That's why Rich wants the Super Bowl quarterback back under center. "That's my two cents on the subject matter. Obviously, stay tuned."
Watch the full interview with Jaxon Smith Njigba on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.