To explain how wild Kirk Cousins' return to Minnesota is, Rich went back to April 28, 2012, the day he showed up at Radio City Music Hall for the final four rounds of the NFL Draft.
That draft opened with Andrew Luck to the Colts and Robert Griffin III to Washington. Brandon Weeden was the third quarterback taken in round one. Brock Osweiler went in the second round to Denver. In the third round, Russell Wilson went to Seattle and Nick Foles got drafted. Nobody knew what any of it would mean.
And nobody, Rich included, understood why Washington, after spending everything to move up for RG3 at number two, used the seventh pick of the fourth round on a quarterback out of Michigan State named Kirk Cousins.
Rich said so on air, to Mike Mayock. It was the first time in his draft coverage that he had the nerve to look Mayock in the eye and push back. The only way Cousins plays, Rich said, is if something catastrophic happens to RG3. Mayock pushed back.
RG3 had a dynamic rookie season. What nobody knew was that Cousins was about to begin "one of the most fascinating, remarkably well paid" careers in football. Rich did know about Cousins' college career: 4-0 against Michigan and a bowl win over Aaron Murray and Georgia. And the Shanahan family saw him as the holy grail.
RG3 eventually blew out his knee, Cousins got his chance, and he played well enough to become the Shanahan idea for the future, but not well enough for Washington to commit. He was franchise tagged in 2016 for almost $20 million and again in 2017 for $23 million. "You like that?" was born. Then Minnesota called.
The Vikings gave him three years and $84 million, every dollar guaranteed, something Rich had never heard of before. Deshaun Watson later "held that beer." Then came two years and $61 million, then one year and $35 million in 2022.
Six years in Washington and six in Minnesota. No championships, plenty of great games, and plenty of questions about whether he could win in prime time.
Then Atlanta. Four years, $180 million, and the Falcons drafted Michael Penix before Cousins played a snap. "He winds up as the RG III in the equation," Rich said. Penix took over in Week 16 of 2024 and started the next season, and Cousins sat there wearing an earbud. Then Las Vegas, where he won four of his first nine and looked good.
Meanwhile Minnesota tried everything. Sam Darnold, from the Shanahan tree, had a highly successful year and was gone. J.J. McCarthy was dealt this year for a fifth-round pick. Kyler Murray was signed on a $1.3 million deal. Carson Wentz got a shot. And then, at 38, Cousins got the call again.
The Raiders, apparently, let him choose. Rich can't blame him for picking Minnesota. "His clock is ticking like Mona Lisa Vito's foot stamp," Rich said. He knows the coach, the system, the route to the stadium, the people who work there, where to live, where to eat, "and he knows how to feed Justin Jefferson."
It's the perfect way to finish. Rich noted Cousins has made $333 million on contracts and is now being paid by three teams at once: Atlanta, Las Vegas and Minnesota. "This is like Sesame Street sponsored by the number three."
McCarthy, asked at the podium about the move, said he wished Cousins "nothing but the best of luck" and called it a great fit. Rich's takeaway: never play poker with J.J. McCarthy.
The return comes with symmetry. Cousins' first game back is at Lambeau Field, where he played his last game as a Viking in 2023, playing well until he tore his Achilles with 10 minutes left. Win there and Minnesota sweeps Green Bay after beating them in Week 1. Then it's Mexico City against San Francisco, the Shanahan team everyone was sure would sign Cousins before it traded for Jimmy Garoppolo instead. Then Penix.
Raiders general manager John Spytek said he never made a call on Cousins. "I got a few phone calls, but one real one this morning." Rich figures the Vikings' hair was on fire after Monday night and they went to the guy they knew.
Vikings fans just watched the Brewers next door hoist a trophy and the Knicks do what they did. A Cousins ring, Rich said, "would track."
"Oh, he's never going to start. Oh, he's never going to stay. Oh, he's never going to stick," Rich said. "Crazier things, man. What an avatar for you never know."
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.