Jeremy Fowler had just told the show the Niners are hoping to get Mike Evans back this week. Rich's first thought was about the grass.
"This guy who's got Achilles issues, amongst many others, you want to put him on foreign turf, literally and figuratively?" Rich asked. "You want to put him on the field in Mexico City?"
He admitted he had no idea what the surface would be like, and wondered aloud whether the league's "sod god," George Toma, was putting it together. His instinct was to hold Evans out.
The catch is what comes two weeks later. The 49ers have to go to MetLife Stadium, "the place they do not want to go," as Rich put it.
The desk went further. Sit everybody. Throw the game if you have to. Bosa, the room imagined, would be thrilled to hear he has to play out there again.
"Everybody talks about the substation. That's not real, okay?" one voice said. "You know what's real? That MetLife turf."
Rich said every Niner fan knows exactly what he means. "How many times they wind up going to MetLife, somebody gets hurt, and they're at the podium or in their locker room afterwards saying, what's going on around here?" And the Giants, he added, are better than at any time San Francisco has been there.
So he built a schedule-management plan on the fly. Sit Evans in Mexico City. Play him at home against Seattle. Sit him again at the Giants. Then everyone is healthy for the stretch run.
The desk wanted to extend the plan to McCaffrey too. Getting Keenan Allen helps the receiver room, and Kittle is coming off an Achilles injury, so caution was the theme. "Sit them all," came the suggestion.
After the Giants, the Niners are home against the Rams and then at the Chargers on a Thursday night. "They got a fun schedule," the room agreed.
None of that changes this weekend's appeal. The Niners are 8-1, and they face Minnesota in Mexico City on Sunday Night Football.
"Niners are always must-see TV, man," Rich said, before closing with a little Spanish for the occasion.
The desk caught it right away.
"I did."
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.