Are We Going To See An NFL Seeding Rules Change?
Watch on YouTube 2:44

Are We Going To See An NFL Seeding Rules Change?

The question on the table: will this year's NFC South finally force the NFL to change its playoff seeding rules? Rich says it is already there. As far as he's concerned, the case is already made, and he brought the fix with him.

Rich used the Bears as his example. Say Chicago finishes second in its division and ends up the five seed. That means a wild-card trip to the NFC South winner, which could be not just under .500 but deeply under .500.

"Seven and 10," came the suggestion from the studio.

Rich accepted that. An 8-9 division winner is something he could almost look past, because a coin flip here and a coin flip there and it's a .500 team. But 7-10 is worse. And six and 11? The room didn't want to imagine it.

The part that bothers Rich most is how likely the worst case is. The Bears could easily have already beaten that NFC South team. They could have swept the entire division. And they could still have to go into that team's stadium on wild-card weekend, in a win-or-go-home game, while the home team gets the crowd.

"Which is absurd," Rich said. "It's absurd."

The show doesn't just howl at the moon, Rich said. It provides a fix.

The rule: if you win your division, you get a home playoff game, unless you're under .500 and the five seed is above .500 by at least as many games as you're below it. The five seed needs as many wins over losses as you have losses over wins.

In practice, an 8-9 division winner keeps its home game against a 9-8 wild card. It loses that game to a 10-7 wild card.

"That's the answer," Rich said. "Simple math."

The same logic holds further down. A 7-10 division winner facing a 10-7 wild card loses home field, because the wild card is just as far above .500 as the division winner is below it. Same or worse, and you're on the road while the best wild card hosts.

It's a clean proposal. Division titles still matter, and an 8-9 champion isn't punished for a tight finish. But a team with a losing record can no longer host a clearly better team just because of how the divisions were drawn.

The studio signed off on it immediately. "Sold."

Rich had the closing line ready. "Put it in front of the membership and rip the knob off."

Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
Segment