Week 7 delivered a defending champion waking up, an unbeaten team getting erased, and a Michigan quarterback winning in a Giants uniform. Chris Brockman brought the hottest takes to Overreaction Monday, and Rich sorted the real from the ridiculous.
Chris started where he always starts, with Sunday night. "The champs are back," he said. "Seahawks are going to win the West and they were right to let Kenneth Walker leave in free agency." Rich had seen the first part coming. If there had been a prop bet on Walker being held out of the end zone or under 100 yards, he said he "would have put a significant chunk" on it, because Seattle was never letting Walker come back into that building "and having a night."
Pumping the brakes on the rest, Rich noted Seattle is still behind San Francisco and the two meet in Week 12, with plenty of road left. He did concede the 49ers looked depleted in Atlanta, where, he pointed out, they had not won since Steve Mariucci was the coach and Terrell Owens scored two touchdowns. His verdict: a great win, "Pelt on the wall. Helmet on the spear," but an overreaction.
Next, the Chiefs. "They're not good enough offensively to be real Super Bowl contenders," Chris said. Rich offered a stat that helped Chris's case: Patrick Mahomes has now gone back-to-back games without a passing or rushing touchdown for the first time in his career. Mahomes threw for a season-low 165 yards on Sunday night, only 15 more than Jaxon Smith-Njigba had receiving.
Rich thinks Kansas City needs a move at the trade deadline, just not an A-list one that costs a first or second-round pick. The name floating around most is Garrett Wilson of the Jets, a guy who "hardly lost in college" and "has now gotten his brains beaten in for half a decade." Tyreek Hill is out there too. Rashee Rice has to come back, and Xavier Worthy is still a player Rich is waiting to see turn into Matthew Golden. Asked how far away an uncomfortable Mahomes conversation is, Rich answered: "Zero weeks." Still, a win in Denver would put the Chiefs four quarters from essentially wrapping up the division, so he called it "half a reaction proper and half over."
Chris then threw what he called a curveball right down the middle: "J.J. McCarthy's going to make the playoffs this year and the Vikings will not." Rich split the baby. Minnesota's defense, he said, is "too damn good," and he does not see seven or eight losses on the schedule. He did note that Kyler Murray now has two last-undefeated teams on his resume, and the first one did not end well "because you didn't have the defense to underpin it."
On McCarthy, Rich had no patience for the old criticism. "Oh, all he does is hand it off," he mocked, before pointing out that McCarthy avoided mistakes and made the throws that needed to be made against Houston. He credited John Harbaugh for having "the stones" to bring in a quarterback from Jackson Dart's age group and invite "a first-class problem down the road." Harbaugh challenged the running back room after sending Najee Harris packing, and all three remaining backs scored against the Texans. At 4-2-1, with Philadelphia and Washington coming out of the bye, the Giants could be 6-2-1 with a win over Dallas already in their back pocket. Asked to pick between Jim Harbaugh and Justin Herbert or John Harbaugh and McCarthy, Rich did not hesitate. "One is 0 and 6 and the other one's 4-2-1. Come on now."
Chris moved to Cleveland, where Deshaun Watson now has five comeback wins and, in Chris's view, the Browns "won't finish worse than second in the AFC North." Rich would not go there. Every team in that division is still above .500, so Cleveland could finish fourth with a winning record. He did salute the numbers: Watson is the third quarterback in the Super Bowl era to lead a fourth-quarter or overtime game-winning drive in each of his first five wins of a season, joining Matthew Stafford in 2016 and Troy Aikman in 1990. Rich also noted that Todd Monken said on Friday's show that the Browns had to start faster, then watched them fall behind 14-0 to Tennessee and win anyway. Overreaction, but kudos.
The Raiders take was a mouthful: start Fernando Mendoza in Week 8 and have the Vikings trade for Kirk Cousins. Rich rejected both halves. Minnesota has Kyler Murray on a $1.3 million contract and Carson Wentz behind him. As for Las Vegas, the next stretch runs at the Jets, at San Francisco, home for Seattle, at Denver and at Cleveland. "You just saw what Seattle did to a Mount Rushmore quarterback," Rich said. Let Cousins take that gauntlet, then hand Mendoza the post-bye stretch. "That's my first overall draft choice," Rich said. "I'm not throwing him out there" into that.
On the Rams, Chris argued they still need a receiver before the deadline. Rich was in the gray area. Kyren Williams and Blake Corum both topped 90 rushing yards with a touchdown, and Matthew Stafford threw three touchdown passes in the first half, tying a career high. The bigger issue is health, and the Rams, Rich noted, are out of draft picks to give.
Chris also crowned the Buccaneers the team to beat in the NFC South after Baker Mayfield won with 64 passing yards. Rich called it an overreaction, though he enjoyed the history: the fewest passing yards in a Bucs win since Trent Dilfer threw for 50 against the 1999 Seahawks. Bryce Young, he said, looked like a plaything, "like a cat trying to slap around something with catnip in it."
The one take Rich fully endorsed was Chris calling the Bears the team to beat in the NFC. "I don't think that's an overreaction," Rich said, comparing Caleb Williams to Mahomes: "Play's over. No, it's not." Chicago's first test is a Monday night trip to Seattle.
The tweet of the week, from Alex Dodge, claimed the NFC North will be the first division to put all four teams in the playoffs. Rich shot it down, since Seattle and San Francisco should both get in out of the West. He also used it to vent about Green Bay, which now has eight roughing the passer penalties when nobody else has more than four. Replay assist is allowed to pick those flags up, and Rich wants it to start doing so. Dean Blandino is coming to the studio on Thursday to talk about it.
Watch the full interview on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.
Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.