Actor David Corenswet Talks ‘Mr. Irrelevant,’ ‘Superman’ & More with Rich Eisen | Full Interview
Watch on YouTube 20:54

Actor David Corenswet Talks ‘Mr. Irrelevant,’ ‘Superman’ & More with Rich

David Corenswet has now played the first pick and the last pick. Superman, as Rich put it, is about as first overall as superheroes get. And in Mr. Irrelevant, in theaters nationwide on Christmas Day, Corenswet plays John Tuggle, the last pick of the 1983 NFL Draft and the first Mr. Irrelevant to make the roster of the team that drafted him.

"Yeah, I either have to retire now," Corenswet joked, "or I guess you're just kind of filling in the gaps in between."

Rich called the film beautiful and remarkable, and said he got goosebumps just talking about it because he knows the story. Tuggle was a Cal Bear who played in the famous Stanford-Cal game, came out of the same draft as first overall pick John Elway, and the film follows him from draft day to his final day.

Corenswet said the pressure of portraying a real person was lighter here than it would be for, say, Bill Parcells or LT, people whose images are imprinted on the public. Most football fans don't know Tuggle's name. Cal fans do, and a lot of Giants fans have heard of him, but he played one remarkable season a long time ago.

What the production committed to was his spirit. "A love for the game, an optimism," Corenswet said. He pointed to the scene where Tuggle keeps getting knocked down by LT and just wants to run the play again to see if he can find a way around him. "He was the kind of guy who just willed success into existence." Then Tuggle faces illness, his own mortality and the loss of his dream, and the film asks what he does with that.

His research started with ESPN's 30 for 30 episode, The Irrelevant Giant, which includes an interview with Bill Parcells about Tuggle's impact on him. The production got access to the full TV interviews behind the short clips in that piece, roughly 20 to 25 minutes of footage from 1983 through 1985. In one, Tuggle has just made the squad and is on top of the world. In another, he has been diagnosed with cancer and stepped away.

NFL Films game footage told him something else. Tuggle played a lot of kickoff and punt coverage, and every time he made a tackle he hopped up and looked around at his teammates, on a Giants team that was losing a lot. "Isn't this awesome that we're here in the NFL? Every time," Corenswet said. That gratitude, along with the grit and physicality, was the energy he brought to every scene.

Rich added a detail of his own. Tuggle wasn't just a guy who made the occasional tackle; he became special teams player of the year. Rich's colleague Mike Mayock played special teams for the Giants back then, and his name plate appears in the film next to Harry Carson's. Mayock told Rich that Parcells really did take a liking to Tuggle, and that relationship is on screen.

Corenswet knew the bulking routine from Superman. He weighed a little under 200 pounds before that role and got up to 240. About a year later, prepping for Mr. Irrelevant, he knew 240 was physically possible and aimed for it again, shooting the first half of the movie around 235 to 240.

What he hadn't counted on was the running. Two weeks into training he developed terrible shin splints, and kept them through the entire shoot.

"How does one handle that?" Rich asked.

"You just suffer," Corenswet said. He tried ice, stretches and massage, and learned that nothing helps shin splints like six weeks of rest, which he didn't get until filming ended. In scenes where he is simply jogging across the field, he was often icing his shins between takes so he could jog normally. "The guy just never stopped and I couldn't stop either."

Why not stay at 240? "I would if it were easier," he said. Staying there means a life of thinking about eating, eating, digesting and thinking about eating again. "I'd rather have two eggs for breakfast than eight." He likes feeling solid for a role, filling out a t-shirt, giving a powerful hug. "But gosh, it's a lot of work."

It gave him real respect for players. "Just staying healthy and playing the game, let alone taking the hits, giving the hits, let alone the mental stuff," he said.

He also took real hits for the first time. Corenswet didn't play contact sports growing up, so this was the first time he ever got hit by a guy or got to hit one. In the Lawrence Taylor scenes, "that's me some of the time," he said, while crediting his football double, Jacob, for the really gnarly ones.

Corenswet never met Parcells. "He's up there in Saratoga Springs betting the ponies," Rich offered. But Corenswet said he felt like he met him in spirit through Michael Shannon, who was reportedly skeptical at first about playing the coach. Corenswet said Shannon has what Parcells had: a wry, childlike sense of humor, a love of busting balls, and incredible commitment to the craft. Shannon walked on set with no ego, wanting only to make each scene as good as it could be. Then there are the shorts. "Wait till you see the legs," Corenswet said. "Shannon's got a hell of a pair of gams on him."

He also praised Isabel May, who plays his love interest. Corenswet said it is hard to come in as a supporting player and contribute without making it about yourself, and "you couldn't have asked for a better dance partner." Leonard Marshall, Tuggle's training camp roommate, talked with Corenswet before and after seeing the film and felt it captured something real about Tuggle. "He was moved, and that meant the most to us."

On the football side, NFL Films consulted on the script, and a veteran football coordinator Corenswet called Coach Mike served as the translator between football people and filmmakers, who mean very different things by "blocking." The film shot in Melbourne, so many of the players were Australian and new to American rules, and they ran the same plays dozens of times in heat and weather. "Every shot you see in the movie, you see real football violence going on," he said.

Asked about the toughest part of Superman, Corenswet listed the weight gain and the wire and stunt work. Then he went to something Christopher Reeve said before shooting the original: ultimately it's just you out there in the tights, and nobody is coming to save you.

"Sometimes the biggest challenge was just standing there for a scene in the tights, in the trunks," Corenswet said, and finding a way not to feel silly without overcompensating by acting too tough or shying away from it. He loves that the character is proud to be the big red and blue. "He'll just stand there in his trunks and maybe you'll laugh at him, but he'll be happy to have made you laugh."

Rich couldn't believe he ever felt silly. Corenswet said it helped whenever someone said, "Oh my god, it's Superman," and he'd carry that confidence into the next scene. It was harder standing across from Rachel Brosnahan, looking sharp, and Nicholas Hoult in tailored suits and a big green war suit in the sequel. "Why can't I get some armor?"

His favorite scene was the interview with Brosnahan, the first scene they shot, over two days, which felt like a 1950s Cary Grant movie. Pushed for something more superheroic, he picked the trailer moment where he shields a girl as barrels explode past them, shot practically. He also said the next film, finished this summer, ups its game on flying and fights. Rich wants him back for Man of Tomorrow next summer, and Corenswet said he'd love to come.

His advice for anyone still doubting the tights problem: "Try wearing your underwear on the outside for one day."

Watch the full interview with David Corenswet on The Rich Eisen Show, streaming live on Disney+ weekdays Noon-3PM ET.

Adapted from the original segment on The Rich Eisen Show. How we cover the show.

Explore More
Segment
In This Interview
Actor David Corenswet: The Hardest Part about Playing Superman Is…? | The Rich Eisen Show
Actor David Corenswet: The Hardest Part about Playing Superman Is…? | The Rich Eisen Show
David Corenswet on Getting Swole to Portray ’83 Giants' Inspiring ‘Mr. Irrelevant’ | Rich Eisen Show
David Corenswet on Getting Swole to Portray ’83 Giants' Inspiring ‘Mr. Irrelevant’ | Rich Eisen Show
Related Clips
Rich Tries HARD to Get 'I Play Rocky' Star Anthony Ippolito to Do His Sylvester Stallone Voice
Rich Tries HARD to Get 'I Play Rocky' Star Anthony Ippolito to Do His Sylvester Stallone Voice
Celebrity True or False: U2 Talks Frank Sinatra, 'The Joshua Tree' & More | The Rich Eisen Show
Celebrity True or False: U2 Talks Frank Sinatra, 'The Joshua Tree' & More | The Rich Eisen Show